Mal Meninga Vs Steve Renouf.?

Question

Who was the best?

Im going for Meninga.

Answer 1

Mal

Answer 2

Both superb players, but for me it has to be Meninga, he just had it all! Renouf scored some tries though!

Answer 3

I think that Mal Meninga was the better of the two, but Steve Renouf has a Camel. How cool is that?

Answer 4

Mal Meninga by a country mile!

Answer 5

i've only ever seen Meninga on tele, but my god i was blown away, i saw Renouf alot whilst he was at Wigan but he doesnt compare to big Mal.

Answer 6

Meninga was probably the most complete Rugby League player ever. His closest rival in my opinion being Ellery Hanley.

Renouf is devastating at try scoring, especially from short distances, but his all round game is not of the same standard as the other two.

All personal opinion of course.

Answer 7

Definitely Mal. Complete package

Answer 8

Smell MaFinger is an internationally renown legend.

Steve who?