Manic Panic and Punky colour without bleach?

Question

I'm looking to dye my hair a deep red similar to the one shown here.http://www.manicpanic.com/images2/bestofbest/vampred5.jpg.

I'm looking to use a semi permanent dye without bleaching my hair. My hair colour is brown/black and I was wondering if anyone knows which would work best on my hair. All claim to give subtle colour to black hair.

Punky Colour Red

Manic Panic Divine Wine

Manic Panic Vampire Red

Manic Panic Deadly Nightshade

Any tips for making the colour show would be appreciated also

Answer 1

i would go with either vampire red or punky color red

Answer 2

look at the first pic in my album http://s524.photobucket.com/albums/cc329...

its a little lighter than what you probably want, but it looks totally sweet.