Marshawn Lynch + Nate Burleson for Larry Johnson and Jerry Porter, who wins?

Question

Who wins?

Answer 1

Lynch is up in the air, too many rookies in trouble, Burleson some production.

Larr Johnson a brusing back coming off a season ending injury, and  Porter, who hasn't show'd much in Oakland for at least 4 years

I'd call i a toss up, both could win, both could lose.

Answer 2

I actually like LJ and Porter better.  LJ is getting a bum rap for an off year.  He will rebound.  OL is healthy and better.  Porter still has talent and is happier on his new team.  Lynch looks like he might have off field troubles  and Burleson just plain sucks as a WR (he is a good KR).  Hope this helps.

Answer 3

defintely the people getting LJ have the better deal. buf rb's have always been low scoring and inconsistent (hi mcgahee). nate had a good year last year, but that was because bobby engram was injured. he may have a good year again, and is a decent bench player, but you can't use him as a starter yet. porter is a definite starter in a larger league.

nate has good upside, but LJ has HUGE upside. remember, just 2 AND 3 years ago, he was getting 17-19 td's.

that being said, nate is my sleeper pick this year, and I wouldn't trade him. if that was me, i would try to rework the deal so that i can get LJ, trade marshawn, and keep nate.

Answer 4

larry johnson and jerry porter wins, lynch has some issues and burelson isn't amazing but ok, LJ is a top 5 back when hes healthy, and the chiefs really improved their offensive line so theirs nothing standing in his way he should put up big numbers

Answer 5

The Marshawn/Burleson side.

I'm not a believer in LJ this year but I do like Lynch more. Plus Burleson had 9 TDs last year. Take the Lynch/Burleson side.