Martial Arts Instruction

Question

I have Shorin Ryu and Kenpo training. I am time pressed. Any opinions on the Adrian Roman Distance Learning Kenpo program or suggestions for other programs? What about Shotokan? There is a less expensive school that isn't a sport karate school. I'm into self defense and forms not into sport fighting like my Kenpo school. Any other suggestions? My current school is so big that maybe I get 5 minutes a class with an instructor if I'm lucky so I'm not progressing. I figured at least video study would let me concentrate on the techniques.

Answer 1

Video can't correct mistakes. Best thing to do is talk to your Sensei about the situation. If that does not work out then find another dojo. One where you would get more personal attention.

Answer 2

You should discuss your feelings with your instructor.  If they are not resolved, then you should try the less expensive school.

Video training can be useful if you have an area or a partner to study with.  It is difficult to learn on your own because no one can see you perform a move to tell if you are doing it correctly.

James

Answer 3

I'm not a huge fan of video learning either, but if you HAVE to do videos I have a couple of suggestions.

1 - get a video camera set up to film yourself - I've done this when I didn't have an instructor, and it's very helpful for checking your stance, angles, form, etc.

2 - make sure you work out with a partner as often as you can.  There is no substitute for partner work and a qualified instructor is vital for making real progress.

Regarding self defense vs sport schools, I'm a sport fighter that is studying in a self-defense school.  I see that there is a lot of cross-over in my case (we do Muay Thai, BJJ, JKD).  The point is that you can get a lot of self defense technique from sport training and vice versa - but you need a good school, and a good instructor.

I recommend you check out some other local schools - even ones that you don't think fit your needs.  Have a discussion with the instructors and let them know what you are after.  Find someone you like and give it a try - especially since you are clearly unhappy with the current school's lack of one-on-one time.