Marvin Hagler v Jake LaMotta who wins?

Question

at middleweight, both in their prime. 15 rounds.

Answer 1

Jake LaMotta was a very tough and durable fighter and is well known for his great fights with Sugar Ray Robinson.  I rank Marvin Hagler (tie with Monzon) as the 2nd greatest middleweight champ of all time behind only Robinson.  He could do it all in the ring box, punch, great ring generalship, and very tough with an iron will and jaw.  LaMotta would give him a tough fight but Hagler would land the higher volume of punches.  Hagler by unanimous decision in a good fight.  Good question sir.

Answer 2

Both men had great chin but Marvin has an edge in hand speed and boxing skill. Marvin can win a unanimous decision if he box instead of slug it out. If he slug it out then it will be a 50-50 chance.

Answer 3

wow! what an amazing concept.

this one would push marvin to the limit, only because jake was virtually unstoppable (unknockoutable).

hagler would control most of the action, lamotta would have his moments but hagler ranks up there with robinson, monzon, hopkins and jones jr as the top middleweights of all time........marvin by unanimous decision.....maybe 10-4-1 in rounds.

Answer 4

Wow! What a war.  Jake would last longer than Mugambi did, but eventually Hagler would grind it out.  If Duran could last 15 with Hagler, so would Jake.

Hagler by decision.

Answer 5

Marvellous Marvin Hagler without a doubt. would be a good match but Hagler would be better because of his ability to switch stances.

Answer 6

Jake LaMotta, this guy was tough ...i sure hagler would put up a great match but lamotta never stops punching.....

Answer 7

This is one of the match ups that always stands out for me when i try to work out who i would rate as the best Middleweight of all time. Any fighter who stood in front of Hagler and tried to fight toe to toe got absolutely destroyed (with the exception of Duran). I know Lamotta had a great chin but Marvins was better and i really cant see LaMotta being able to stand and brawl with Hagler as Hagler was a real big puncher and Jake wasnt a big puncher in reality, the result in this fight would be inevitable for me Hagler stops Jake by around round 10 and Lamotta considers retiring after taking the biggest beating of his career.

Answer 8

Marvin Hagler would win by knockout.

Answer 9

This would be a bloody war between two legends, it would definetely be similar to hagler vs hearns but it will end in a victory for hagler.