Mary Kay or Almay waterproof mascara?

Question

which ones better?

or what is YOUR favourite waterproof, uncloggy mascara...

note it must be available in BROWN not black.

Answer 1

I haven't been able to find ANYTHING in years that doesn't flake off and leave me looking like a cadaver by about 1:00 pm.

I have tried Almay in that time, and haven't used Mary Kay in years...go with that.  It may be that long ago since I had anything good.  Hey, that's a really good idea.  Just found out a friend of mine is a consultant.  I should call her.

Answer 2

i have ALMAY in brown and i find it to be really good!

its not cloggy or anything!

my eyes usually swell with eye products, i'm allergic to something lol but i use the mascara and the eyeliner from almay and my eyes are fine!

the colour lasts all day too  

Answer 3

i loveeeeeeeeeeeee maybelline long lash extreme mascaras. i always get compliments on my eyelashes.  

Answer 4

ALMAY IS DEF. THE BEST =)

Answer 5

mary kay is better