Matt Holliday for Josh Hamilton?

Question

Holliday has the pedigree, but Hamilton has been an absolute stud this year. Who would you rather have?

Answer 1

Josh Hamilton. As the guy above me said, the teams themselves matter the most. The Rockies aren't doing anything this year so Holliday doesn't get the chance to use that power to full potential.

Answer 2

Hamliton, the Rangers are packing heat 1 through 5 (Kinsler, Young, Josh, MB, Murph) this gives him runs to drive in and to be driven in.

Holliday still has power, but in a less productive Rockies lineup he wont get as many chances.

Answer 3

Matt Holliday.

Answer 4

Hamilton