May Somebody Please Rank My Fantasy Football Team?

Question

I'm in a 4 man league because we want a "ALL OUT" action packed game every week with a superstar line-up

This is my line-up...I had the first round pick

Ben Roethisberger

Donovan Mcnabb

Terrell Owens

T.J. Houshmandzadeh

Steve Smith

Plaxico Burress

Torry Holt

Anquan Boldin

Hines Ward

LaDainian Tomlinson

Clinton Portis

Reggie Bush

Rudi Johnson

Michael Turner

Fred Taylor

Chris Cooley

Vernon Davis

New England Defense

no bench players at all!!!. just them all in each game!

vrs. my opponent

peyton manning

carson palmer

wes welker

andre johnson

roy williams

santonio holmes

Lee Evans

calvin johnson

adrian peterson

ryan grant

steven jackson

maurice jones drew

ronnie brown

darren mcfadden

jamal lewis

dallas clark

donald lee

san diego defense

Answer 1

Hi Jack,

It's really difficult to judge a team packed with studs because it leaves no room for criticisms.  In a league with 4 teams I think you guys are indirectly leaving your league's fate strictly to chance.  Fantasy football is fun when you have to use strategy, but in leagues where all teams are loaded with studs the strategy component generally goes out the window.  

Obviously your team is stacked, but I'm not sure how to rank a team against other teams that are equally stacked.  I guess my answer would be that both teams listed are equally outstanding.  But again, what fun is playing in a league where every team is a stud-farm?  

You guys may put up a lot of points, but you're doing so at the expense of the fun components of league play: finding sleepers, developing waiver-wire strategy, finding the diamond in the rough, underdog upsets, etc.

If you guys like this format then I say stick with it, but I would rather configure my league such that the champion is ideally the player who drafted best and made the best moves throughout the season; I would not want the league champion to be determined by chance because all teams are equally devastating.

If you would like to create your own fantasy cheat sheets using drag and drop, check out the link in my source list.  It's free.