Miguel Cabrera or Ryan Braun?

Question

Right now I have Cabrera. He's been disappointing so far, but he can flat out hit. I think he'll end the year strong. In my league, Cabrera is 1B and 3B eligible.

As for Braun, he has been picking up his game. His numbers look great. My only issue is that I'm in a league that counts Walks and Strikeouts (Two areas that actually hurt Braun's value). In my league he is 3B and LF eligible.

Both are great hitters. Who would you rather have?

Answer 1

It usually depends on what you have....but I would take Braun.

When he became OF eligible...I moved him to my OF and traded for Aramis Ramirez. Since then, I've been great.

But I would take Braun.