Mookie Wilson or Gaylord Perry?

Question

lol toughguy, I'm leaving it up to the answerer's imagination. I just wanted to put both players in the same sentence.

Answer 1

Gaylord Perry

Answer 2

It wasn't illegal to use a spitball back then Vito, so I choose him. You could say anyone is good without something but you have to take to account what they can do what they can't. So the better player is Perry

Answer 3

Gaylord Perry

im only saying that becuase im a giants fan

Answer 4

Wilson, because Perry is nothing without his Spitball.  I don't really like cheaters, so I'll take the one who plays by the rules.

Answer 5

First of all how do you compare a non pitcher to an everyday player and how do you compare a Hall of Famer to an average ballplayer?  Your question makes absolutely no sense to be brutally honest with you.  If you would have compared Perry to Phil Niekro, it would have made sense and been more interesting.  Now back to your question, Gaylord Perry is much better than Wilson.