Most Underrated/Overrated Players in baseball...playoffs Continued!!?

Question

Pick the winner of each match up. The winners will go on to the championship round.

Last round Re-cap:

UNDERRATED:

Curtis Granderson over Placido Polanco 14-7

Justin Morneau over Adrian Gonzalez 11-10

Matt Cain over Nate McLouth 12 - 10

Yadier Molina over Brandon Phillips 11-10

OVERRATED:

Barry Zito over Jason Varitek 12-9

Derek Jeter over Vladimir Guererro 18-3

Dontrelle Willis over Robinson Cano 15-5

Andruw Jones over Carlos Delgado 14-4

Round 2:

UNDERRATED:

Curtis Granderson v. Yadier Molina

Justin Morneau v. Matt Cain

OVERRATED:

Barry Zito v. Dontrelle Willis

Andruw Jones v. Derek Jeter

Once again, these players were voted. I did not select them.

Answer 1

Derek Jeter = Over-HATED

Answer 2

molina over granderson

morneau over cain

i dont like jeter but the guy has won a ton of world series

and willis is in class a ball so he's not overated

jones over jeter

zito over willis

Answer 3

yadier molina

matt cain

Barry zito

Andruw Jones

Answer 4

Underrated winner: Molina and Morneau

Overrated winner : Willis and DEREK JETER he has the cheapest hits and how the h**l is he starting the all star game with his batting avg. being .285 thats such bullshit and also what 6 homeruns and 48 rbis i think micheal young should be there or since a rod is so dam good let him play both positions 3rd and short stop

Answer 5

under

cain and molina

over zito and jones

Answer 6

Granderson

Cain (neither have made playoffs I don't think)

Zito (Willis and Beckett carried Marlins to World Series)

Jones (Jeter led Yanks to world series 4 times)

Answer 7

why did the total number of votes vary from 18-22?

and

Yadier Molina

Matt Cain

Dontrelle Willis

Andruw Jones

Answer 8

Molina over Granderson

Cain over Morneau

Zito over Willis

Jeter over Jones

Answer 9

I say Curtis Granderson and Justin Morneau for Underrated.

Barry Zito and Andruw Jones for Overrated. You can't really call Dontrelle Willis Overrated when he has been injured most of the season.

Answer 10

Curtis Granderson

Justin Morneau

Dontrelle Willis

Andruw Jones

Answer 11

Underrated:

Justin Morneau

Overrated:

Derek Jeter

To bad it can't just be all of the Yankees 2000-2008