Most Underrated/Overrated Players in baseball...playoffs!?

Question

These are the playoffs for most underrated and overrated players in baseball. I picked all of them based on the votes in my last question. So vote for the winner of each head to head matchup.

Round 1: Underrated

Curtis Granderson v. Placido Polanco

Justin Morneau v. Adrian Gonzalez

Nate McLouth v. Matt Cain

Brandon Phillips v. Yadier Molina

Round 1: Overrated

Barry Zito v. Jason Varitek

Derek Jeter v. Vladimir Guererro

Dontrell Willis v. Robinson Cano

Andruw Jones v. Carlos Delgado

*I did not pick these top 8 players, I based it off the votes in my last question. Just an fyi.

Answer 1

Underrated

Granderson

Gonzalez

Cain

Molina

Overrated

Varitek

Jeter

Cano

Delgado

Answer 2

Granderson

Morneau

Cain

Molina

Zito

Jeter

Cano

Jones

Answer 3

1.placido

2.morneu

3.cain

4.molina

1.zito

2.jeter

3.willis

4.Delgado

here are some more underated... ryan braun jacoby elsbury ben sheets but i agree with u the whole way

Answer 4

Granderson

Gonzalez

Mclouth

Phillips

Varitek

Jeter

Cano

Jones

Answer 5

Underrated:

1. Granderson

2. Morneau

3. Cain

4. Phillips

Overrated:

1. Zito

2. Jeter

3. Willis

4. Jones

Answer 6

UNDERRATED

Granderson over Polanco

Gonzalez over Morneau (Morneau is making almost 9 mil/year, Gonzalez isn't even making 1)

McLouth over Cain

Phillips over Molina

OVERRATED

Zito over Varitek (Cmon Zito...14 mil and you get sent to the minors?)

Jeter over Gurerro (Vlad has a lot more power and speed. Jeter can play a better defense though)

Willis Over Cano

Delgado over Jones (Delgado is definitely not worth the 16 mil the Mets are giving him.Hes a 10-12mil guy.)

Answer 7

Curtis Granderson

Adrian Gonzalez

Nate McLouth

Yadier Molina

Barry Zito

Derek Jeter

Dontrelle Willis

Andruw Jones

Answer 8

Polanco

Gonzalez

Cain

Phillips

Varitek

Jeter

Willis

Jones

Answer 9

Curtis Granderson

Justin Morneau

Nate McLouth

Yadier Molina

Barry Zito

Derek Jeter

Dontrelle Willis

Andruw Jones

Answer 10

Round 1: Underrated

Polanco

Gonzalez

Cain

Phillips

Round 1: Overrated

Varitek

Jeter

D-train

Jones

Answer 11

polanco

gonzalez

mclouth

phillips

varitek (zito is no longer overrated)

(neither are overrated) jeter

willis

jones(delgado is probably gonna win nl player of the month!)

Answer 12

Curtis Granderson tops with his speed, and abillity to play center left and right field. Morneau beats Gonzalez. No Qeustion about it. Matt Cain beats Nat McLouth. And Yadier Molina tops Brandon Phillips with his abillity. Name that Molina. Lol. Barry Zito way more overated than Varitek. Zito plain out sucks this year. Jeter. Vlad is just to good with speed and power. Dontrell Willis. He sucks. He cant win a game or go 3 innings without getting hurt. Boo. Andruw

Jones. What has he done this year! Boo. Go Geldago.

Round 2 : Granderson still edges out Morneau with speed.

Cain is elminated by Molina.

Zito advances past Jeter because Jeter is a great player just matched up in first round against a better player, and Willis goes to finals also.

So most Underated = Granderson

Overated= Willis

Answer 13

Granderson

Gonzalez

McLouth

Phillips

Varitek

Guererro

Willis

Jones

Answer 14

Underrated

Placido Polanco - better player

Adrian Gonzalez - very close but Morneau gets more press

Nate McLouth

Yadier Molina - best defensive catcher in the game and hits .300~

Overrated

Barry Zito - worst free agenst signing in history

Derek Jeter - not deserving of most of the credit he gets and I dont think Vlad belongs here

Dontrell Willis - hes not getting it done right now; Cano at least contributes

Answer 15

Granderson

Morneau

Cain

Yadier Molina

Zito

Jeter

Cano

Jones

Answer 16

Granderson is more underated than Polanco

Morneau more than Gonzalex

McLouth more than Cain

Phillips never gets any press despite great play, so this one has to be Phillips.

Zito isn't rated highly anymore, so I'll go with Varitek

Jeter is more overated than Vlad by a mile (Vlad's a great player)

Willis is more overated than Cano

Jones flopped this year, but over his career, I don't think either Jone or Delgado were overated, so I'll call this one  a tie.

Answer 17

Granderson

Morneau

McLouth

Molina

Varitek

Jeter

Willis

Delgado

Answer 18

Placido Polanco

Adrian Gonzalez

Matt Cain

Brandon Phillips

Barry Zito

Vladimir Guererro (even tho i am Angels fan)

Robinson Cano (Willis helped marlins win W.S ???)

Andruw Jones

Answer 19

Round 1: Underrated

Curtis Granderson v. Placido Polanco--Polanco

Justin Morneau v. Adrian Gonzalez--Morneau

Nate McLouth v. Matt Cain--Cain(even tho i love McLouth tho)

Brandon Phillips v. Yadier Molina--Phillips, very underrated

Round 1: Overrated

Barry Zito v. Jason Varitek--Zito(ppl finally learn to hit his slow curve, the same slow curve that baffled hitters when Zito first entered the league...Barry, in the majors, you need a fastball that clocks atleast 85)

Derek Jeter v. Vladimir Guererro--Jeter, i dont think Vlad is overrated

Dontrell Willis v. Robinson Cano---Willis, i dont htink Cano is overrated. But WIllis have had 2 good seasons when he entered the league, but 0 since.

Andruw Jones v. Carlos Delgado-Jones.  Idk what happened to him.  He used to be smaller and faster.  NOw he can't even hit above hte mendoza line.

Answer 20

Granderson over Polanco

Moreneau over Gonzalez

Cain over Mcloutch

Phillips over Molina

Varitek over Zito

Vlad over Jeter

Willis over Cano

Jones over Delgado