Muslims, Prove to me that muhammed is the Holy Spirit?

Question

Please explain how Jesus said "John the Baptist baptized with water but I will baptize by fire" and in Acts 2, tongues of flame descended upon the gathered apostles before they were able to communicate in other languages. I am interested in this because someone replied that muhammed was the Holy Spirit.

Answer 1

Okay with all of the impossible explanations of how a corrupt Bible proves a prophet that disagrees with it...How prey tell does the book of John announce Muhammad...when according to the Qu'ran the gospel was handed to Christ and the book of John was written after the resurrection?????

Answer 2

Proof of any holy spirit is impossible, and the concept is nonsensical, anyway.

Answer 3

he was the last messenger of god.he was a man like you and me.allah sent the quran to prophet muhammad(pbuh) through gibraeel and sometimes straight to him.humans are above angles

Answer 4

Patrick thinky u dumb

Answer 5

y duh h**l do u wanna talk to MUSLIMS??

Theyre all TERROISTS heading strait to h**l

Allah will give them flames, not virgins!!!

THOSE b******s WANNA KILL AMERICA

an then they complain about us

KEEL ALL MUSLIMS

MCCAIN 08!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 6

The believe the Holy Spirit is angel Gabriel.  They believe the Comforter, which is the Holy Spirit, is in reference to Muhammad.  They also believe the Bible is corrupt so why would they think a reference to Muhammad found in it is accurate?  The whole islam belief is a twisted version of Christianity.

John 14:16-18 And I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for even  the Spirit of truth; whom the world cannot receive, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him: but ye know him; for he dwelleth with you, and shall be in you.  I will not leave you comfortless: I will come to you.  

The Comforter will abide with you forever - neither Muhammad or the Angel Gabriel fit this.  

Jesus said He will NOT leave you (disciples, all of us) comfortless - Muhammad didn't come until 600 years later!

The Comforter will be IN you - neither Gabriel or Mo can do this.  Only God, The Holy Spirit, can!

Answer 7

My understanding is that Muhammad is not considered to be the Holy Spirit. I read somewhere that Muslims believe that the Angel Gabriel (Jibril) was.

Jesus' prophecy in John 14, refers to a Comforter. That was from the Greek word Parakletos (Paraclete), that I understand was translated as Ahmad, another form of Muhammad. My understanding is that Muslims believe that

Muhammad was the prophesied Comforter.

Christians interpret this Comforter as the Holy Spirit (who they now believe is a Person of the Triune God) that came upon the disciples in Acts 2. That doesn't mean that Muhammad was the Holy Spirit. Muhammad and the Holy Spirit were different ways of interpreting the prophesied Comforter.

Additional

I wrote my answer before your addition. It seems to be a rant rather than a reasoned thought. I personally have no axe to grind, since I'm not a believer myself.

Answer 8

no Muslim in his/her right mind would ever say that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is THE Holy spirit. but if you mean in John 14:16 the greek word "paraclete" then check out this study

http://www.islam4all.com/newpage8.htm

Answer 9

uhh Muslims don't believe that Muhammad was a "Holy Spirit" lol, we only believe that he was the last messenger of God...