My NFL QB Power Rankings. Who likes?

Question

(Provided Healthy)

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Donovan McNabb

6. Marc Bulger

7. Carson Palmer

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Derek Anderson

10. Matt Hasselbeck

11. David Garrard

12. Jake Delhomme

13. Jay Cutler

14. Philip Rivers

15. Trent Edwards

16. Jason Campbell

17. Aaron Rodgers

18. Vince Young

19. Matt Schaub

20. Jamarcus Russell

13.

Answer 1

why u have jamarcu russell on there and cutler b4 rivers is beyond me

Answer 2

Brady before Oblong Head.

Answer 3

It's good. Here would be my top 10.

10. Marc Bulger (You Ranked 6)

9. Tony Romo (You ranked 3)

8. Eli Manning (You didn't rank him)

7. Carson Palmer (You ranked 7 as well)

6. Drew Brees (You ranked 4)

5. Ben Roethlisberger (You ranked 8)

4. Donovan McNabb (You ranked 5)

3. Brett Favre (You didn't rank him)

2. Tom Brady (You ranked him 1)

1. Peyton Manning (You ranked him 2)  

Answer 4

Romo at # 3?

I don't need to read on, I know your list sucks.

There are at least 5 guys below Romo that should not be.

Plus you ranked Derek Anderson over Hasselbeck?  wtf

Answer 5

Replace Russell with Tarvaris Jackson (more playing time and yards)

Answer 6

Peyton Manning before Tom Brady.  Everything else is irrelevant.

Answer 7

You said if healthy, which is a big IF for Donovan McNabb. No way Marc Bulger is better than Carson Palmer and Big Ben.

Also, Trent Edwards is a little bit too high and not better than Vince Young.

Answer 8

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. David Garrard

6. Derek Anderson

7. Philip Rivers

8. Matt Schaub

9. Donovan Mcnabb

10. Ben Roethlisbergr

11. Carson Palmer

12. Aaron Rodgers

13. Jay Cutler

14. Matt Hasselbeck

15. Marc Bulger

I based my rankings upon health, last season's results, and returning superstars on their offense.

Answer 9

If you dont give the best answer to me, please dont give it to schuy 7 because that guy knows nothing about QBs at all. This list is very good.....but I think Young is better than Trent Edwards. Trent is decent, but he plays kind of scared. That game when they almost beat the Cowboys I saw a wideout split their cover two perfectly. He was too scared to take it, so he threw it short to a TE instead of going for the deep throw. Vince can win games, kina like Vick used to. He has an advantage because he has a nice defence though. Vince is kinda garbage, but he is better than Trent I think.

I would also put a healty McNabb over Drew Brees any day. Have you seen the stats for McNabb on a full season compared to those of Brees?  

Answer 10

P. Manning b4 Brady! and where's E. Manning???

Answer 11

Wel done.  My only criticism would be McNabb at 5.  I'm predicting he'll play more like a ten.

Answer 12

Not bad. I think your top 5 are perfect. I think bulger could drop down the chain a little though. And I would move hasselback up to maybe 6 or 7. IMO he is the most underrated QB in all of football. Most overrated goes to Vince Young no question.

Answer 13

I move both Garrard and Schaub up 4 spots.  Good list though.

Answer 14

heres mine

1,Brady (of course)

2,P.Manning

3,Brees

4,Big ben

5,Tony Romo

6,Palmer

7,Bulger

8,Anderson

9,garrard

10,Hasselback

11,McNabb

12,Cutler

13,Delhomme

14,Rivers.

15,Schaub

16,Edwards

17,Campbell

18,Rodgers

19,Young

20,Russel

Answer 15

i myself don't agree with afew of your rankings

1. doesn't matter who you rank here Peyton or Brady they are the two best in the league right now.

3.Carson Palmer has better mechanics then Romo

4.Drew Brees

5.Jake Delhomme the most accurate QB in the league and is very underrated (but you said providing that they are healthy)

6.Matt Hasselbeck very consistent with no out standing WR.

7 Ben Roethlisberger

8 Tony Romo alot of talent but still a loose cannon

9 Marc Bulger

10 Donovan McNabb the most over rated QB in the league plus injury prone.

the next ten have still to prove themselfs to me at least are they a one year wonders or can they cut the mustard

11 Derek Anderson outstanding year

12 David Garrard play very smart football and did well and i like him

13 Eli Manning still alot to learn

14 Jay Cutler not completely sold on him as a starter

15 Jason Campbell showed promise before he got hurt

16 Matt Schaub  same as Campbell

17 Phillip Rivers into himself more then his team show alot of promise in college but not as a pro

18 Trent Edward rough start better this year i hope alot of talent on his team

19 Vince Young goes here only because the other two haven't really had alot of playing time

20 Aaron Rodgers

21 Jamarcus Russell

Answer 16

Peyton should b #1 duh he is way better

GO COLTS

Answer 17

Cutler is better than 13 and Young is better than 18.

I think Palmer will be in the top 4 this year.

Answer 18

vince young is better than 18 in my opinion...........but its a good list

Answer 19

Bulger might be too high.  He could drop down to 10 and Hasselbeck should jump up to 7 with Carson palmer at 6 I would still like to wait and see on Anderson for next season.  I don't love Garrard either, he was efficient but didn't put up very big numbers.  I take Rivers over him.  Also Eli manning is conspicuously absent from your list.  Super Bowl champs!  

Answer 20

Thats a good list. Your top 5 are perfect but i think you were a little off near the bottom.