My starting QB is Peyton Manning, but would Aaron Rodgers make a good backup?

Question

i'm in an 8 team yahoo league, head to head

Answer 1

Yes

Answer 2

I think Rodgers will make a good backup.  I think he is going to surprise people and move the GB offense well.

Answer 3

You got a prized pick for QB.  As for a backup I would not be enthusiatic with Aaron Rodgers.  Not that I don't think he will do well. I just don't see games where he will do better then Peyton.  Looking at the Packers schedule, they face alot of solid defenses this year. (vikings, Bears, Colts, Bucs, Tennesse, Jaguars, etc.) The only team I see that will probably have a weak pass rush and secondary is against Detriot.  

http://www.nfl.com/teams/schedule?team=G...

Answer 4

I'd say so, the Packers have a great receiving group. He'll put up some solid numbers.  

Answer 5

no I think you should get philip rivers or billy volek for a backup  

Answer 6

nah, that would mean aaron rodgers is a top 16 qb. he's not. in an 8 team league there are many better choices that are more proven. he's not worth a pick in an 8 team draft unless he starts lighting it up.

Answer 7

yes he would be a great backup since he is a starter on a playoff team