NFL Fantasy trade proposal Kitna for Vince Young?

Question

The trade proposal is me giving up Vince Young and Darrell Jackson for Jon Kitna. Should I do it.

Answer 1

I would do it.  

Answer 2

HELLLLLLLLLLLLLLL NO! Boy are you crazy. John Kitna is nobody. Not only can Vince Young throw but he can run too. I wouldn't even trade just Darrell Jackson for Kitna. He's horrible!

Answer 3

In general I'd rather have Jon Kitna than Vince Young.  He's thrown for over 4000 yrds in each of his two Lions seasons.  He'll probably get you 21 TDs and 22 TO's this year.  VY will probably get you about 3000 total yrds with 16 tds and 19 TO's.  Fantasywise, Kitna's the better investment but your starting QB's bye-week matchup should really be your deciding factor (these guys are for backup QB position, right?).

So how much do you value Darrell Jackson?  He had 3 TD catches last year after a 10 TD season in Seattle the year before.  I think he'll catch 5-6 TD passes next season, if he comes into this year motivated... which has been a while.

If you can target a WR you feel good about to take up Jackson's spot, I'd probably accept the offer.

Answer 4

No, Darrell who!?! and Kitna is the interception king. Do this trade if you are trying to fall in the bottom 5.

Answer 5

no