Navy or Marines?(advice)

Question

I just want to know some differences between the services before I make a decision. first off, what would make you choose the Marines over joining the Navy and vice verses. Are Marines generally tougher when it comes to discipline and following orders? basically I just want to know the differences between the services for someone who has actually been there. what would make you choose one over the other?

Answer 1

the marines

but if you want the best for your family if you do get married and settle down the air force is the way to go. i know this isnt in your options but they take the best care of your family have better bases and housing than all the other military branchs

best of luck on choosing

Answer 2

I served 24 years in the Navy and LOVED it - that is because I chose a job field that inspired me and challenged me - that is the key - for any service.  The USMC does give you a stronger discipline but I have a sone in the Marines and another in the Army - both have had little time for education. I am a big advocate of the free educational benefits the military keeps promoting. The Navy encourages education.

I also have a son in the Navy - he just started college.

it is really your choice - but make sure anything you talk to a recruiter about is IN WRITING and you do well on the ASVAB so you qualify for  a job you will love - HAVE FUN and GOOD LUCK!

Answer 3

Well I would choose the USMC over the Navy because I am interested in serving in the infantry and the Navy can not help me there.

If subs and ships were ini my interest radar then I would choose the Navy..

Yes the USMC stresses discipline alot more as it is required for their mission and Marines tend to be in overall better shape due to the nature of their mission.

The two branches are not similar and your either cut out for one or the other, so the choice should be a very simple one.

And just because some Marines serve on ships does not mean the two are the same, because what Marines do while on those ships will never be done by anyone other then Marines.

Answer 4

my husband was in the USMC for 7 years, my uncle was in for 26 and my aunt for 18. they "discuss" the differences all the time.

the Marines are tougher, they are taught to fight on land. As where they Navy are taught to fight on sea. to me the USMC is a physically demanding job, one of the most. You go on hikes for 13 miles, train in deserts, mountains and oceans to fight physically an enemy. whereas in the navy, you are more trained to swim. you spend six months out of the year on a ship. so being in physically top shape isnt such a priority.

my husband chose the USMC because they are one of the few, the proud. they are an elite force of the military. they are known for their strength, stamina, and intelligence (Dont let the jarhead name fool you). being a Marine is a privilege and a honor. as you can tell i am biased.  

Answer 5

In todays Armed Forces most people are looking for what will benifit them in the short term. IE.. Tuition for College, Experience in a non-combat role "Safe Mode" do their time and leave. Its more taken as a job than a life. The Marine Corps because of its Mission teachers leadership,Espirt de Corps from the first time you put your feet on the yellow footprints. A Sergeant E-5 can lead a Platoon has where a CPO E-7 may have 10 people working for him/her. The roles of leadership are completly different. With some exceptions such as the SEALs or Boat teams. In the Navy most people have the opportunity to continue their education as where as most Marines deploy so often that is nearly impossible to go to college. In answer to why I became a Marine. Because I wanted to make a difference in my life and be part of the Greatest Brotherhood on this Earth.

Semper Fi and Good Luck!

Answer 6

I think a better question is what do you want to do. Your career path should be the factor in deciding which service to go with. Both are great! They both fall under the Department of the Navy. Both have GI Bills and the same pay-grade. Go see a Marines and a Navy recruiter. They should be helpful in figuring out where you'd like to serve.

Answer 7

I think if you want a better perspective and answers from true sailors, active or retired you should go to http://mynavyonline.com it's a great source for all kinds of information, from enlisting to job descriptions to everything else.