Need Help with Trade! 10 pts?

Question

My RB's are Willis Mcgahee and Justin Fargas. My backup QB is Favre. Should I trade WIllis McGahee and Brett Favre for Steven Jackson?

Best Advice Gets 10 pts

Answer 1

I would do this because you get a top 5 running back for a bench player and a decent starter. The only thing is i might try to give up the same people for Joseph Addai or Brian Westbrook. But either way it helps your team

Answer 2

i think that this is a good trade for you, but more importantly whoever you send this to will not accept this trade. word out of baltimore is that ray rice is having a great preseason and will demand carries in the regular season and we all know that mcgahee has a hard time staying healthy. and everyone knows that favre is having a hard time learning the jets system and his arm is tired....thats like having a shooter with a tired finger. so in conclusion this would be a good trade but your better off trading  for a better backup qb, and trading favre for a rb  like thomas jones because i dont think favre and mcgahee are worth a top 5 rb. but thats just my opinion

Answer 3

unless the other person has told you he will make that trade.. realistically he wont make the trade. you might have to give up some better quality players to get this trade to go threw. but if you can do it go for it.. it would sure be a steal

Answer 4

No. What you should do is make Favre your starting QB, and trade Willis McGahee with another good player for Steven Jackson. Hope I helped! Peace.

Answer 5

Willis Mcgahee had almost 30 more fantasy points than Steven Jackson last year..... And true Mcgahee has been injury pronged in the past ...... even then he put up better number than Jackson.....Further more Jackson hasn't been to camp all year until now..... he hasn't been working out or drilling like Mcgahee has..... And why would you keep Fargas over Mcgahee????  Fargas is gonna have his job swiped by McFadden!!!!!

Best advice..... Either trade  Justin Fargas and Brett Favre for Steven Jackson or don't trade at all!!!!

Answer 6

It really depends on who your starting QB is, and if there is another decent backup QB available in your league.  Steven Jackson is a great upgrade over McGahee, but if you leave yourself in trouble at QB, you might regret the trade later.

Answer 7

Yes, McGahee is very injury prone and wont last 10 games. Jackson will have his best year. Favre is a back-up to who? I hope you got a good one......TRADE TRADE TRADE