Need help choosing the right eyeliner

Question

I have tried using millions of different types of eyeliners, and nothing seems to work on me. All of the ones that say waterproof, come off within 15 minutes. I've spent $20 on Sephora Waterproof eyeliner, it was supposed to be the best in the store, and it still started wearing off as soon as i walked out the door. I really need something that will last for a couple of hours or more and SOON, because i need it for school! thanks mucho!

Answer 1

Mac black fluidliner

shiseido liquid eyeliner

Answer 2

Le kohl eyeliner by: L'oreal

its really good

Answer 3

Estee Lauder eye liner is AMAZING, and it stays on very well and pretty long. Also, it is really not that expensive! Check this out: http://www.esteelauder.com/templates/pro...

Hope you find it to your liking as much as I do!!! :)  

Answer 4

Bobbi Brown gel eyeliners dry like cement and last all day plus.  You can get them at Nordstrom.

Answer 5

Ok... i know it's incredibly expensive... but i've been told by one of my friends (who is a makeup fanatic) that Chanel is practically bullet proof.

It's like AU$80, but aparently it's worth it, it stays on all day/night.

I know it's a very expensive brand, but save up (like me) and get it! :)

Answer 6

Studio Gear Eyeliner is the best eyeliner I have ever used in my life!

http://www.studiogearcosmetics.net/home....

It is found in ULTA stores.

Answer 7

Well....

Revlon Colorstay eyeliner works for me... did you get colorstay?

Sephora slim eyeliner pencils have also worked.

If you truly can't find a good pencil eyeliner, then I suggest you get liquid eyeliner. Maybelline Ultra Liner is waterproof and will stay on all day.

Another one is by Wet 'N' Wild called H20 Proof Liquid Eyeliner, but I don't suggest this one because it's super messy and impossible to take off. I was rubbing at my eyes for like 20 min -_-.  

Answer 8

I have wonderful eyeliner but it is not waterproof but it totally works believe me I am in school and sports and it dose not come off it is called Jordana you can get it at any local Walgreens! it is on sale right now for about $2 and they have a verity of different colors. It is retractable eyeliner so it is in a tube .Don't get pencil eyeliner  because when you sharpen it you could get some of the wood in your eyes and it hurts really badly, and don't get liquid eyeliner because it is just groddie!