Neville should of killed Bellatrix???

Question

Does anyone else think that Neville should of killed Bellatrix?

Answer 1

Not necessarily!

JK probably didn't want the good charactors going in for revenge but I do see your point.

BTW... I know I am annoying but in your name it should be You're  not your.

Answer 2

h**l, yes!

I thought the whole point of writing in the Longbottom/Lestrange history was that Neville would finally get to avenge his parents on Bellatrix. After having him kill Nagini, he should have polished her off too!.

I also don't like the way Molly killed Bella. I mean, a woman who has spent her whole adult life bringing up her children to behave ad not swear is not suddenly going to yell the word ***** in front of a large crowd. And this fight just came out of the blue, with no build-up to it whatsoever. "She is mine!" why? Molly may never have seen Bella in her life until that point, why suddenly declare a vendetta now? I think JKR could have something so much better sith this scene.

Sorry about the rant. I just think Neville should have killed Bellatrix.

Answer 3

I'm a little on the fence about this it would have been totally awesome to see Neville get revenge, but then again i think that would ruin his air innocence. I'm happy that he got to kill Nagini though, that would have felt invigorating!

>>TOWG<<

Answer 4

Well I thought there were a couple of possiblities of who might kill Bellatrix : One of whom was Neville

Then I also thought of Hermione, because of the way she crucio'ed her, and Harry Because of Sirius.

But I think ultimately Jo made the right decision, Because we are inclined to assume that Molly weasley isnt much of a good witch, because she is a house-wife. But I think it was her way of showing the hidden diamond!

I simply loved the fact that Molly Killed Bella, because it showed a parents love and goodness and willingness to protect the world for her children.

So yes, I think Neville would have been justified if it had been him, but I think Jo made the right decision!

Answer 5

No, not at all...

Answer 6

No, in the last book he rebeled against authority, but it would of been too much if he killed Bellatrix. He's to innocent, not a murderer!

Answer 7

Yer, I agree with the previous answer, maybe it would have been a bit of obvious if Neville or Harry killed her. It kind of showed us the thing that Dumbledore was always saying: about love and friendships triumphing over evil etc. And that seen when Molly says "NOT MY DAUGHTER YOU *****" is just so funny.

Answer 8

No, I don't.

I think Neville should HAVE killed Bellatrix.

I actually don't care, but I needed to point that out.

Also...

YOU'RE = you are

YOUR = your!

Hey! Don't give ME a thumbs down! I'm trying to help people with their English. I'm sorry if you think that's BAD.

im' maekin teh wrold a beterr plece wih edutcashon but wood u rater hav    a world were people ca'nt tipe!tha'ts woot i thot?...!

Answer 9

noooo.

then he would have split his soul.

who cares about molly!

Answer 10

I agree with Ginerva.

Neville would have killed Bella.

If it was me, I would have blasted her into smitherings.