Of these three SS, which would you want on your fantasy squad?

Question

Pick TWO of the following options at SS:

Carlos Guillén (1B/3B/SS) [DET]

Édgar Rentería (SS) [DET]

Christian Guzman (SS) [NATS]

If Guzman is traded to a team that has some supporting players, he should have a ridiculous second half. On the other hand, I still think Detroit stands a decent chance at making a run at the AL Central if their offense keeps up the tear they've been on as of late.

Answer 1

Easily Guillen for one.

then Guzman. Renteria nahhh

Answer 2

Renteria. Guillen makes a lot of errors, and you never hear about Guzman because he's on a small-market team.

Answer 3

Guzman is doing good in the worst lineup in baseball. Guillen's position eligibility makes him more valuable than Renteria. I'd take Guzman and Guillen.

Answer 4

Don't be mislead by Guzman's strong year so far.  He will fade in the 2nd half...plus, he doesn't hit many HRs or produce many runs.  I rank them: 1. Guillen, Renteria, then Guzman.  Renteria will come around.  He always does.