Offered this trade (fantasy football)?

Question

I trade QB Eli Manning for RBs Jamal Lewis and Michael Turner.

My roster: http://games.espn.go.com/ffl/clubhouse?leagueId=122119&teamId=1

His roster: http://games.espn.go.com/ffl/clubhouse?leagueId=122119&teamId=7&seasonId=2008

I will likely decline this trade, because while it would give me two good RBs, I would be down to one QB (Matt Hasselbeck) and there are decent ones in free agency (http://games.espn.go.com/ffl/freeagency?leagueId=122119&teamId=1&slotCategoryId=0)

Answer 1

good trade

Answer 2

Take it, it's hard to get good RB's and I think Turned will have a big year.

Answer 3

Do that trade! Drop Ahmad Bradshaw and look to trade LenDale White. Pick-up Vince Young to back-up Hasselbeck.

Answer 4

I don't have to even look at your roster and I can tell you to take the trade.

Just because Eli was in the Super Bowl last year doesn't make him some great QB with fantasy value.

Hasselbeck threw for 600 more yards, 5 more TDs, 7 less INTs and had a QB rating of 91.4 compared to Eli's 73.9 rating.

Hasselbeck is easily the better QB hands down.

So if some idiot wants to give you 2 top level RBs for Eli, let him have him, AND FAST before he sobers up.

Answer 5

I would have taken the offer.

Answer 6

TAKE THE TRADE IT IS ONLY A 10 TEAM LEAGUE AND YOU ONLY NEED AN EXTRA QB FOR ONE WEEK AND THERE ARE 32 QB'S TAKE A FLYER ON  WARNER OR LEINHART FOR THAT WEEK

Answer 7

I would have taken that trade.  2 RBs...for an average QB.  Hasselbeck will start most games.  Heck...you could probably trade Lewis for Cutler or someone else.  That lets you keep Turner for free and nobody knows how he will do.  A great sleeper.