On present performance, is Gary Ablett junior equal to or better than Chris Judd?

Question

The Roo opinion is that he is at least the equal of Judd.

I think he may be better - maybe partly because he doesn't have as much belief in his own legend as Mr Judd. But it's certainly a tough call.

In order to measure objectivity, please put your team allegiance on the bottom of your views, which are invited!

Answer 1

judd WAS awsome. explosive,but that will never be again. his body is thrashed to the point of no return. he still breaks out of nowhere here and there these days, but by the looks of abblett over the last two years.......he is one of a kind. a magician. as much as i hate geelong, he is the player to beat this year, and probably for many more years to come. cant keep my eyes off his game. bloody inspiring.

I'm a Crows fan

Answer 2

It's obvious who i support, what i would give to have these two at my club.

what did you mean by this statement,

(i think he may be better - maybe partly because he doesn't have as much belief in his own legend as Mr Judd.)

Judd isn't up himself, if that what you are implying, he hasn't got a conceited bone in his body.  To answer your question, on present form you would have to say Ablett, although Judd did play a pearler of a game over the weekend.

Answer 3

Gary ablett is better right now, but you have to consider Judd is out of form at the moment and he is still recovering from injuries. Both are awesome players though.

I am not biased because I go for crows.

Go Crows!!!!!!!

Answer 4

lol. Chriss Juddd isnt back to his VERY best yettt

His close. When Juddy gets back to his best, Abblett will look like a rookie :P.

Atm they're about the same...Ablett may be a LITTLE beta

Answer 5

At the moment Ablett is playing better than Judd, but that may be because Judd is at around 85% fitness following his groin injury, and Ablett is at his peak... However, with both of them at 100% it would be very difficult to choose!