P. Manning or Brady?

Question

P. Manning or Brady?

Answer 1

Well it's definitely Brady for all the reasons everyone on here has already said. The people who still say Manning usually can't back it up with fact or are still clinging to him being a number 1 draft pick, which doesn't mean anything, or all the records he's broke... many of which Brady broke last season while setting some new NFL records of his own. And Brady is whiney? I mean... I'm not sure where certain people got that from. I mean... every now and then the guy gets on the ref for what he thinks was a late hit or a penalty that shouldn't be called, but that's what QB's are supposed to do... they are the leader of their team. It's VERY rare you see Brady get that way though. You'll never see him complaining about anything in a press conference about how he was wronged on the field... ever... and even when he is asked about occassionally losing his cool he just jokes about it and proceeds to talk up the other team. People just hate a constant winner so they harp on ANYTHING they think is unbecoming. Tomlinson is very whiney and talks so much trash and is constantly seen getting visibly upset on the sidelines and the guy is the best at his position and his team is great, but since his team hasn't won three superbowls his attitude isn't magnified.

Edit: To Jones above me. Brady is the better leader... what do you base your opinion on Manning being a better leader. Alot of people on his team have talked about how he isolates himself from the others, while Brady is friends with everyone on his team... most particularly his offensive line. Even though he's recently been cut from the Pats... Marcus Pollard talked about how in just one offseason from working with Brady he said he's never been around such a great team leader before. Considering he played most of his career with the Colts... I think that would include Manning.

Answer 2

Manning by far Tom Brady wouldn't have touched that record without Moss ... the guy who 23 of the 50 touchdowns on passes that would have never been completed if Randy Moss couldn't jump 2 feet above everyone else. Peyton has never had the guy making amazing catches just running great routes that would look horrible if they didn't have Peyton Manning performing surgery on your favorite teams defense.

Answer 3

Ill have to say Manning, he is just a lot more impressive at leading his team.  I dont particular like either of these guys, but from what i have seen most people who say Brady are either Pats fans or those that just hate Manning for whatever reason.

Answer 4

Tom Brady - 78% winning percentage (82% in postseason), 3 titles, TD record, perfect season....

Peyton Manning - 66% winning percentage (50% in postseason), 1 title....

Answer 5

Neither!

Not Tom Brady because he gets very whiny. But he is a better player than Manning.

Definitely not Peyton because he's an arrogant piece of work.

If for quarterbacks, Ben Roethlisberger is a recommendation to go with.

For me, I'd rather go with Brady.  

Answer 6

This must be the most over-asked question of the last decade.

Answer 7

I don't think either are better than the other.. but I know Peyton doesn't want non of Cromartie though.

Answer 8

Brady you dumb moron

Answer 9

Manning period.