PAUL COLLINGWOOD'S POSITION IN THE TEAM SEEMS UNCERTAIN. Will FREEDIE'S RETURN DARKEN PAULS' FUTURE??

Question

If thought simply, then England have only P.Collingwood as an good all-rounder in the team. O.Shah also bowls but he is not as good as Paul. SHAH is a good batsman no-doubt, but replacing Collingwood againest Oasis...............well...................

Answer 1

No...........

Paul is a bit too good to be left out of the team..........

Moreover one cannot compare the hard-hitting of Paul with Freddie's performance......

Freddie will also make way in England's team; but at the cost of someone else........

Answer 2

nope he only have five or 6 bad games. he is good player// freddie got war of place in team from anderson and broad

Answer 3

I think you are right as i to see he is the one who has to make way for Freddie.

Answer 4

Freddie will come in for Anderson or Broad, if he continues to bat poorly. If Flintoff regains his match winning batting form of 2003-2005 then he will surely come in the team either for Bell or Collingwood.

Owais Shah is the man, who can kick Colly out of the test team, he is a wonderful batsmen, far better than Collingwood the only question is can he handle the pressure of test cricket? If so Owais Shah can finally cement his place in the England test team if given the chance. There's also Rob Key

To sum up- Flintoff in for Anderson or Broad. Simon Jones in for Anderson or Broad and Shah in for Collingwood. So Yes Collingwood place in under threat but by Shah and NOT Flintoff

EDIT- Collingwood's medium pacers are scarecly used in test cricket, he is not a wicket-taking option he just bowls to give the main bowlers a rest and to try and buy a wicket. Shah is far more talented than Collingwood! England need runs! Shah can give you them! they dont need a decent batsmen and an average medium pacer!

Shah in, Collingwood out IMO END OF

Answer 5

God knows.

Answer 6

flintoff rocks and

colingwood safe

Answer 7

Freedie is much better player than Paul Collingwood provided Freedie keeps himself fit to play.

Answer 8

Definitely Flintoff in for Colly.  Stuart Broad's the only real all rounder now, Flintoff only bats well ocassionally and Colly's not much of a bowler!

Answer 9

if flintoff comes back , collingwood would lose his place