Pedro or Randy?

Question

I wish this was about 5-7 years ago, but I have Randy Johnson and Pedro Martinez right now, and I am thinking of dropping one of them for Keppinger because I am in need of a SS. Who should I drop, if either of them?

Answer 1

You've got to drop Pedro.  Personally, I think his days of pitching are numbered.  Every time he comes off the DL or is on a rehab assignment, he gets hurt.  Randy is actually out there and pitching, and pitching well at that.  By the way, I wouldn't pick up Keppinger if I were you.  He's just coming off the DL and I don't see him keeping up with what he did before the DL.  I'd try for someone else, maybe with a trade involving Pedro, Randy, or both.

Answer 2

Drop Pedro, he can't stay healthy. Both of them will get injured and out from the season at some point. It's really a coin flip.

Pick up Izturis, dude's got skills.

Answer 3

Drop Pedro obviously...RJ is actually pitching and hes on a team that can win.  Pedro is on and off the DL and im not even sure hes active right now but the Mets are bad and so is Pedro hes done.  

Keppinger is the best SS you can get?  I dont even think h**l play everday at SS.  

Anyways drop Pedro