Pedroia, Sizemore, and McLouth for Utley?

Question

I possess Utley, and I have space to put Sizmore and McLouth on the roster. So, Deal or No Deal?

Answer 1

YES! YES! YES!

Pedroia ain't no Utley but he has lead the league (still may) in multi hit games.

Answer 2

Ooo Utley is the best player in baseball but Sizemore is hitting his stride and he does everything so well. I would probably accept it, especially if you want the OF help

Answer 3

Do it. I gave up Utley for Jose Reyes, JJ Putz (before he was injured) and Bobby Jenks.