Peyton Manning vs.Tom Brady

Question

Ok let's suppose both these guys got injured in week 1 and put on the injured reserve. Which team would be more fu*ked?

Answer 1

Colts patriots team is well put together

Answer 2

New England

Answer 3

They both root for USC!!!!

Answer 4

the patriots. colts have a better back up QB and RB. i wish tom brady would get hurt. not bad enough to end his career. just enough to show him he's not as great as he thinks he is.  

Answer 5

pats. colts are an all-around good football team. take away brady or moss on the patriots and they're just an average team.

Answer 6

Patriots would be done for.  They dont have a RB that is consistent.  Neither of them would make the playoffs.

Answer 7

patriots have an amazing organization, i believe they would do better they have backups peyton dosnt..

Answer 8

has to be the colts, the pats have a great coach and knows how to win without brady, but the colts had peyton starting since he cam to the NFL, so they are not use to having a different quarterback  

Answer 9

The Colts, because the Patriots would just upgrade their camera system.

Answer 10

Both.......................Equally fornicated

Answer 11

Colts would be more screwed for one obvious reason. Veterans

Manning and Saturday, Clark, Wayne, Harrison, and even Addai on on the same page. It's tough to keep all that in tact for as long as the Colts organization has. That's the key to their success. Brady has worked with many different people over the last few years and done well. I've noticed the first group of guys in the preseason Colts games getting frustrated with Sorgi. I think Gray and Lorenzen are both better than Mannings backup Sorgi. I think the Pats would be able to manage the game but both could miss the playoffs.  

Answer 12

the colts because even thou the patriots wont have brady they got marony and hes a great RB and i think randy moss and wes welker would make their second string QB look like a starter.

Answer 13

I really think the Pats would be hurting without Brady, however, I also think that the coaching staff of the Pats are amazing when it comes to using “nobody’s” to help the team out. And that’s exactly what they’d do….

So Indy would be more f**ked.....

Answer 14

Both would be in serious trouble.....

I actually think the Colts might be better because they have a better defense and could maybe beat some teams strictly with their D.

Answer 15

The pats would I can't even name their back up however i know the colts have sorgi and quinn gray who can manage games.

Answer 16

Manning means more to how the Colts run the offense, than Brady.  Losing Manning would be worse, relatively speaking.

...but in actuality, they'd both become "also rans".

Answer 17

I think that they would both be in trouble! I'm personally a Dallas Cowboys fan, but I would feel for the Patriots and the Colts without these guys!

Answer 18

Colts would be more f**ked  the Pats would still have Moss  and what makes the Colts so different and effective is the no huddle offence  can there backup qb handle tht?

Answer 19

The Pats

Colts have a better back up QB and RB