Peyton manning and michael turner for Derek anderson and jamal lewis?

Question

who gets the better end of this trade and why

Answer 1

I would hold on to Turner because he will probably be fielding kick/punt returns like he did last year.  Also, there is no telling how the Falcons are going to do in the passing game and may rely on Turner to carry the ball alot.  Manning is too d**n solid and consistent to be trading away.  Anderson is good but he only produced that one standout season last year with the Browns.  Hang on to both your guys because trading them away might bite you in the long run.

Answer 2

Manning and Turner is way better.

Answer 3

Getting Anderson and Lewis is the plus because they are both good and peyton manning is good but turner has proven nothing and you dont know if he will be splitting carries that much so yeah

Answer 4

The one who is receiving Manning and Turner

Anderson and Lewis are coming off one good year and looking at Cleveland upcoming regular season schedule....this could be tough for the Browns QB and RB

Manning is always going to produce great numbers

Michael Turner is a solid and young RB and is on a team that is REALLY going to EMPHASIZE the run.....I heard a rumor that Turner could be getting 300 or more carries this season

Answer 5

Peyton/Turner get the best deal

Answer 6

If you get Turner and Manning then yes, definitely