Peyton or Eli Manning, who's better?

Question

Just looking for opinions.

Answer 1

Without regard to their superbowl and MVP wins, I would say Peyton.  He is a more complete quarterback at this time, and easily could be the best ever when his career comes to an end.  He not only possesses the skill, but the intelligence and sense on the field that few quarterbacks have.

Answer 2

Eli is good, but I still think he's overrated just because of his last name. Peyton is definitely better, but it's just an opinion.

Answer 3

peyton is much better. eli, even though he got a ring, is still tagging along to peyton. peytons career numbers are going to rival some of the greatest to ever play the game and is sure to win another title, but eli will keep the average numbers and play his way through career with teams hoping he can become peyton. manning is going to be like favre with the colts, play for another 6 years or so there and become the legend in indy, but i think eli will more than likely float around to a couple of teams at the end of his career. i like both qb's but just looking at them you know peyton is better and will always be better.

Answer 4

I would sadly have to say Peyton. But Peyton couldnt lead his team over the Pats, as did  the giants.

Answer 5

Peyton is better

Answer 6

Peyton, because he is more experinced and won a super bowl and despite Eli winning a super bowl himself.

Answer 7

Peyton is better by a wide margin...the only reason it took him longer to win a SB is because the AFC is more competitive than the NFC

Answer 8

Peyton is better than Eli.  He has been much more consistent throughout the seasons.

Answer 9

Peyton