Please critique my band?

Question

The top 6 songs are mine. My favorites are in this order: 1) Penny 2) Where are you wolf 3) Earth's Atmosphere 4) Under their floors 5) Toy Girl.

What can we do to improve? Do we sound like we're ripping off any other band (if so, who)?

Answer 1

Penny, was the best of the songs. That being said, every songs was terrible. It is no surprise you don't have many responses to this question. No one likes to bring the bad news, me, I will give you a 100% honest answer regardless if you are good or bad. And you are not good.

As far as ripping another band off,...hard to tell, no one that bad has even been signed....Please don't give up, I hear, and feel potential, but I really think you need to write some songs that are at least listenable.