Please rate my Fantasy Football Draft?

Question

It's a 12-team, point-per-reception league.

How do you grade it (A is great, F- is Horrible)? And why?

QB: David Garrard, Aaron Rodgers

RB: Westbrook, McGahee, J. Stewart, Chester Taylor, R. Mendenhall

WR: Ocho-Cinco, B. Marshall, J. Cotchery, James Hardy

TE: Alge Crumpler

DEF: Green Bay

PK: Jeff Reed

Answer 1

I give your QBs a C-

Garrad wont give turn the ball over much which is good, but he wont get you many yards or TDs either. Rodgers could do will given his weapons but I don't like first year QBs in fantasy.

Your RB's get an A-

Westbrook has been a great fantasy player and he is finally getting the praise he deserves. Look for him to get lots of carries and catches from the backfield. McGahee is as strong as a second RB as you can get in most leagues. Chester Taylor is a great back-up because Peterson *may* get injured and Taylor will definitly carry the load if that happens.  I like Mendenhall to get a few TDs also.

WR: B-

Chad Johnson seems to be back on pace with the Bengals and Palmer so I think he is undervalued in most drafts this year, however I would not consider him in the elite class of recievers. Marshall is a Terrell Owens waiting to break out. Same type of player and he has a good rep with Cutler, hopefully he can play to his potential. Cotchery is solid considering Farve was added, but other than that nothing special.

TE: C+

Crumpler is declining but you know Vince Young will use him alot

Def: B

They have some playmakers in a weak conference. They will eat up the vikings, lions and bears QBs and O-lines all day.

PK: B-

Solid, old, but reliable

Overall: B-

Answer 2

QB - C+. Both have upward potential though

RB - A. Nice group there. I would have handcuffed McGahee with Ray Rice though

WR - B-. I don't like CJ he's a cancer. Marshall is a beast and Cotchery's value just skyrocketed when the Jets got Favre. Hardy should be interesting in Buffalo a real darkhorse.

TE - B+. Crumpler's career should be revived with Vince Young.

DST - B. Will be inconsistent

PK - B. I like Reed and he's got a decent offense.

Overall: B-  

Answer 3

B-

QB's are a mix of good and bad, Rodgers gets hurt every time he steps on the field and Garrard will be your go to guy

RB's: Westbrook is awesome the rest are mediocre

WR's Watch out for Marshall, he may go down early

The rest are ok....

Answer 4

Westbrook is a monster in PPR.

2 RBs and a Flex?

Stewart in the flex isnt terrible I guess.  Its looks like you reached for Marshall in the 4th round tho.  Wasnt a good RB or a better WR there?  Course, he could pay off and win you the league.  

Also, I like your bench.  Stewart or Mendenhall could turn into something.  AP could get injured (odds are good) and Chester becomes a Top RB.  Cotchery is a guy im targeting now that Favre is there.  I have no idea who Hardy is.  Also, thank you for not drafting a backup TE, DEF, or Kicker.

Im tempted to give you an A because youve got a great mix of reliablity w upside in each position.  Garrardd and Rodgers.  Westbrook/McGahee with Rookies n Taylor.  Cotchery w 85 and Marshall.

You draft a lot like I do btw.  I give you an A.

Answer 5

overall its not bad. ill give u a B

heres what you need to do

-Start rodgers ahead of garrad

-Start Stewart or even mendehall(he'll get alot of carries) if he has a bad defensive team

-Trade Mcgahee

-Get a better TE

Answer 6

I would also give you a B. I think Aaron Rogers will have a tough year this year until he gets on his feet. Everything else looks ok to me.

Answer 7

B

Your weak at QB.  

Answer 8

u got a complete risk-reward QB situation and only two solid backs who could be un-durable, but u got a rookie sleeper (stewart) and 2 guys splitting time (mendenhall and taylor) good recievers with better QB's (exception of james hardy) good TE for when the titans try to pass, he'll be the guy. and a good D, but ur kicker needs to get better, overall i say B, cuz u got a lot of potential sleepers, but keep the team, its a good experiemental year for you. u could go championship or last place, but i say stick with the team u got

Answer 9

QB rating- (B+)-Garrard is a solid qb, and rodgers culd suprise ppl this year

RB rating- (A)- Westbrook, and willis, obviosly solid, but with two rookies?

WR rating (C+)- Johnson might play arena, marshall is out the 1st two games, cotchery might do OK with favre and hardy is goin nowhere fast

TE rating- (D)- Crumpler doesnt play like he used too, enough said

DEF rating- (A-)- I really think GB defense is one of the top in the league this year with woodson, hawk, harris, etc.

PK rating- (A-) what can you say about a kicker, lol

overall (A-) nice team boy