Poll: Who is your #1 favorite pitcher of all-time?

Question

Me: Pedro Martinez/Greg Maddux (tie)

Answer 1

Randy Johnson blew people away. Including a seagul.

Answer 2

tom brady

or brett favre

Answer 3

John Smoltz.

Answer 4

It must be late and all the Ryan boosters are in bed.  Good.

Bob Gibson.  One game to win, I want him on the mound.

Answer 5

tim lincecum

Answer 6

Halladay

Answer 7

Brad Zeigler

Answer 8

All-Time: John Smoltz

Currently: Jon Lester

Answer 9

Babe Ruth  (He was a pitcher before he became a batter) had a 2.14 career ERA for five years before he became a batter

Answer 10

The Doc... Roy Halladay. Every game is like Game 7 World series. You seen when he had a huge lead against the yankees? He walked someone and was disgusted with himself. That is a real man who pitches every pitch like it will be his last. Also a real bullpen savior.

Answer 11

Sandy Koufax

Tom Seaver is a very close second.

Answer 12

Bret Saberhagen barely edges out Greg Maddux  

Answer 13

Black Jack McDowell  

Answer 14

Joe Nathan, Scott Baker, Matt Garza, Gavin Floyd, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster, Tim Lincecum....it's hard to choose just one.

Answer 15

Martinez or Johnson

Answer 16

kurt schilling for the red sox!!!

Answer 17

Jerry Koosman - NY Mets (I was at the 2nd game of the 1969 World Series). Koosman pitched no hit ball for 7 innings and pitched a complete game for the first ever Mets World Series victories. Koosman was an underated lefty.

Answer 18

when i was growing up it was always fun to watch sandy koufax

the best pitcher ever!

Answer 19

First of all /\ Thats football and a quaterback not a pitcher

                

Old pitcher: Rollie Fingers

Current day:Jon Lester

Answer 20

Sandy Koufax  Too bad arthritis cut him down in his prime. Did you know that Koufax never hit a batter? Had a hard time picking Koufax against Bob Gibson. In the 58 season the Dodgers finished 7th in an 8 team league. Koufax was so wild that he only came in when games were totally out of hand. Because of the Bonus Rule of the times he had to stay with major league that signed him. The Dodgers signed him out of the U. of Cincinnati where he had a basketball scholarship. And to close Koufax may have been the worst batter in the game at the time. He once hit a fair ball into right field, the fielder got it on one bounce and threw him out at first.

Answer 21

My son.  He rocks and is only 9 lol.  Look for him in ten years.  Of course I am just bragging.  Martinez is amazing.

Answer 22

the big unit randy johnson. he's awesome with that look to the catcher just before he throws that ball. i watched him back in the day and he just kicked *** on bad teams

Answer 23

Cobb

Answer 24

I have to go with Bob Gibson.

One of the most dominant.

Answer 25

Not best, but favorite:  Sal "The Barber" Maglie, who once threw four knock-down pitches in a row to walk a guy and once beaned someone in the on-deck circle.

Best?  Saitchel Paige.

Answer 26

All time has to be Koufax, and currently its Roy Halladay, i just love his old school type of play.