Possible Twilight plot hole?

Question

Why is it that no one in La push relises that the warewolves are living more then three times a normal human life spand and aren't aging?

also

why is it that Edward couldn't hear Bella's mind when he was in/under her sheild but could hear it when she reclinded it??

Answer 1

Possible plot hole?

The book is loaded of plot holes.

It's like Meyer's trademark.

=)

Answer 2

People don't see what they don't want to see. Or they just ignore.

Edward couldn't hear Bella's mind because her shield prevented it. But when she pulled back her shield, he could, because the shield wasn't being blocking...

Answer 3

See, that's the thing with Twilight. It has more plot holes than swiss cheese.

And we're talking a really BIG piece of swiss cheese.

You just have to use your "imagination," I suppose. After all, as Meyer so proudly states in almost EVERY SINGLE interview, she doesn't think when she's writing and she doesn't plan anything out. I heavily doubt she edits it afterwards, either; why should she, as she views herself as the best writer since the history, of lyk, evr?!1?!1!1?! -coughhack-

Answer 4

because they dont pay attention!! duh!

edward cant hear bellas mind because she is... double shielded lets say. it makes sense that he cant still.

Answer 5

There are many plot holes.

How did Bella get pregnant? How does Renesmee exist, when the only bodily fluids vampires have is venom?

Stephenie Meyer isn't a great writer. That's why they exist.

Edit: Sasha: "Really BIG pieces of Swiss Cheese" HAHA that's funny. AND true.

Answer 6

the La Push people probley don't pay attention and Edward couldn't hear Bella's mind under the shield because no one can get to her mentally under the shield  

Answer 7

Well most people in the book don't believe in vampires and werewolves, so that wouldn't be an option.

And Edward can never hear what Bella is thinking. Nobody knows why, though. Email Stephenie Meyer or something.

Answer 8

The majority of people in La Push already know, so for those who don't "know" they do know the old legends. And I'm sure they have some idea.

That's how Bella's power works, she is able to say who can, and can't get inside her head.

Stephenie Meyer leaves a lot to be inferred, or assumed a lot of times, and a lot of the things take a while to grasp, then your like "Oh.....OH!"

Best of Luck!

Answer 9

i agree

girls are reading the book just to hear about edward and drool over him, instead of paying attention.

everyone in La Push. kind of know this. but they still feel the need to keep it all a secret. you never know...

Bella is double shield. and at the end of the breaking dawn she let edward hear her thoughts.

READ THE BOOK AGAIN...