Pretty Boy Floyd Mayweather vs Sugar Shane Mosley in there primes who wins?

Question

Pretty Boy Floyd Mayweather vs Sugar Shane Mosley in there primes who wins?

Answer 1

Mayweather. They are both quick but Floyd has great defence no one can break it.

Answer 2

The prime Sugar Shane Mosley was 38 - 0 (35 KO)  before losing to Vernon Forrest twice. Mosley was very talented with his fast hands and knockout power. If the prime Mosley can somehow knock the prime Mayweather in the early rounds, it would be hard for Floyd to survive like he always does at the final rounds. If not, Floyd can win a decision.

Answer 3

mosley would win this

mosley has the speed the chin the power and heart  

non of floyds past opponents had that.

floyd pot shots and dances around, mosley throws combos and pressures,

jab judah who has fast hands was giving floyd a tough time for a couple of rounds untill he just quit trying in the later rounds. mosley fights all 12 rounds...

Answer 4

Mosely hes one of the few fighters whos fast enough to catch mayweather and his power has always been very underated. Hes much stronger than mayweather and he has more exp than him has been in a lot more bigger fights. I thought he deserved a draw when he fought cotto , surprised he didnt want an immediate rematch, that would have been a great fight.

Answer 5

I think Floyd would have a slight edge. He is just so fast and such a good defensive fighter. No one has really tested Floyd up to this point in his career. Shane was a great fighter and holds 2 wins over De la Hoya which one is questionable. Also,I think Mayweathers power is a little better than Shane's. It would be a great fight. If I had to predict, i would have to say Floyd by a close unanimous,decision. When I remarked earlier that Floyd has a slight edge in power,I did not mean one-punch power. He seems to wear his opponents down over the course of a fight. I think Shane may have a slight edge in one-punch power..too slight to make a difference.

Answer 6

mayweather, mosley has no defence whatsoever and mayweather is slicker and quicker then forest who absolutly crushed mosley, mosley is still one of my faves but he does not cover up on his left side which is mayweathers money punch. I think mosley would chase and get caught.

It also depends on which mayweather you are talking about, the one that  started 1997-2002 or the boxer slicker one 2004 to now.

either way I say mayweather in a different style you would expect

Answer 7

I have always felt Shane had the answer to Mayweather's style.  I am going against popular opinion on this one, but I think Floyd ducked Shane his entire career because the style match up would be a disaster for Mayweather.  Floyd has been faster and quicker than everyone he has ever faced, even Judah, but Shane is Floyd's equal in hand speed, and even at this late stage in Shane's career I think he could beat Floyd.  Floyd couldn't jab and run from Shane, and Shane is quick enough to answer any flurries Floyd might use to try and steal rounds.

I say Mosley beats Mayweather, and truthfully it's not really that big of an upset.

Answer 8

mayweather.