Pumpkin or sweet potato pie?

Question

What kind do you prefer and why?

Answer 1

Sweet potato all the way. I am from the south and that is the best pie in the world, no nutmeg please!

Answer 2

pumpkin

because sweet potato isnt th greatest.  

Answer 3

Your Answer:

pumpkin I like the flavor better

Answer 4

Love 'em both!

Answer 5

sweet potato but with a twist. bottom is sweet potato, topping is a pecan pie topping. serve warm with ice cream. yummy!

Answer 6

I like pumpkin, or Butternut Squash pie.  I use Butternut in place of pumpkin all the time, and you can't tell the difference!  Plus, Butternut is so much easier to grow than Pumpkin.

Answer 7

Sweet potato pie is my favorite but I like both; I think it's consistency is more pleasant and it does not have as much spice(nutmeg and cloves) in it.

Answer 8

def a pumpkin fan, and if you like molasses, have u ever had shoe fly pie?

Answer 9

I prefer Pumpkin pie over Sweet Potato pie because of all the spices used - it is so creamy and delicious.  Sweet Potato pie tastes bland to me.

WA

Answer 10

never tried either

Answer 11

I love them both.

If given the choice. A nice big slice of Sweet Potato would be in front of me!

Answer 12

I love pumpkin pie and the reason why is because it tastes so good.

Answer 13

I vote Pumpkin!

Answer 14

I like Pumpkin pie the most, sweet potato pie is good, but pumpkin pie seems to be a little creamier and I like the spices.

Answer 15

Pumpkin because I love it and I have never tried sweet potato pie, and I'm not a fan of sweet potatoes = )