Put These Quarterbacks in Top Order from 1 to10?

Question

Out of this list

In Their PRIME who are the TOP 10 Quarterbacks

Derek Anderson

Kyle Boller

Tom Brady

Drew Brees

Marc Bulger

Jason Campbell

David Carr

Brodie Croyle

Jay Cutler

Jake Delhomme

Brett Favre

Jeff Garcia

David Garrard

Kyle Orton

Matt Hasselbeck

Tarvaris Jackson

Jon Kitna

Byron Leftwich

Matt Lienart

J.P. Losman

Eli Manning

Peyton Manning

Donovan Mcnabb

Carson Palmer

Chad Pennington

Philip Rivers

Ben Roethlisberger

Tony Romo

JaMarcus Russel

Matt Schaub

Michael Vick

Kurt Warner

Vince Young

Answer 1

Based on stats, Superbowl, Playoff wins, and current greatness.

1. Peyton Manning

2. Brett Favre

3. Carson Palmer

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Drew Brees

6. Eli Manning

7. Donovan McNabb

8. Phillip Rivers

9. Matt Hasselbeck

10. Kurt Warner

Watch out for David Garrard, Derek Anderson and Jamarcus Russell to make that list.

I don't even know why you put all those names in there? David Carr? Brodie COyle? Kyle Orton?

Tom Brady's off the list since his coach is a cheater n his dynasty was built on referee error (tuck rule)

Answer 2

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Donovan McNabb

4. Brett Favre

5. Carson Palmer

6. Drew Brees

7. Marc Bulger

8. Jay Cutler

9. Philip Rivers

10. Matt Hasselbeck

Answer 3

1. Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Favre - (Hard to know where to rank among top 3)

4. Kurt Warner (2 MVP's in 3 years, before getting hurt)

5. Donovan McNabb

6. Matt Hasselbeck

7. Drew Brees

8. Pennington - possibly the most accurate QB around

9. Garcia

Here's my cop-out - all three of the next are tied for 10. ;-)

e manning

roethlisberger

rivers

Hon. Men.:

romo

palmer

Best young QB: Jay Cutler

Answer 4

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Brett Favre

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Tony Romo

6. Derek Anderson

7. Jay Cutler

8. Drew Brees

9. Eli Manning

10. Carson Palmer

Answer 5

1.Tom Brady

2.Peyton Manning

3.Drew Brees

4.Carson Palmer

5.Brett Favre

6.Donovan Mcnabb

7.David Garrard

8.Eli Manning

9.Yony Romo

10.Matt Hasselbeck  

Answer 6

Thank you for adding the qualifying statement "in their prime".  Important distiction.

This is obviously going to be my opinionated view...

1.  Brett Favre

2.  Tom Brady

3.  Kurt Warner

4.  Peyton Manning

5.  Donovan McNabb

6.  Jeff Garcia

7.  Jake Delhomme

8.  Michael Vick

9.  Carson Palmer

10.  Tony Romo

Interestingly the more I think about it my top 4 is pretty much interchangable in order.  I'm happy with my top 8 in general.  I with you had asked for just top 8.  My last two could have been any number of guys.

Answer 7

1. Brady

2. Farve

3. Manning, Payton

4. Warner

5. Palmer

6. Garcia

7. Roethlisberger

8. Hasselbeck

9. Brees

10. Delhomme

Good Question.... I omitted Romo he has to have more than just one good season to make that list.