Question about Salat! Is your prayer Makrooh?

Question

(1)while praying Salat if you cry from the Fear Of Allah(swt)?

(2)or if Cry remember by someone who already passed away?

(3)or if someone remembers Jahanam, and cry!

Is your prayer Makrooh or Valid!

Jazakumallah khair!!

Answer 1

If you cry in fear of Allah (swt) it is a very good thing, and Allah (swt) is very happy... If you cry in remembrance of a love one who has passed away your salat is Makroo, because you crying for no reason, now crying in remembrance of one is a very good thing if you are doing a Du'a. If you are in fear of Jahanam it is a excellent thing because this almost equal to being afraid of Allah (swt). I hoped I helped. Ramdan Kareem, and may Allah(swt) bless you with all happiness.

Masood  

Answer 2

no it is liked and preferred to cry out of the fear of Jahannam, fear of Allah, fear of grave, fear of death etc.  If you cry after remembering someone's death, and it reminds you of death, or increases you in taqwa then it is a good thing.  If not, as far as i know, nothing wrong with it. becuz u r not complaining, and it is natural for one to get emotional.  but it is important to deal with it according to Islaam.

Allâh the Most High, says:

  "Allâh has sent down the best statement, a Book its part resembling each other in goodness and truth oft repeated. The skins of those who fear their lord shiver from it. Then their skins and hearts soften to the remembrance of Allâh" (39:23)  

  "Those who were given knowledge before it (ie the Jews and Christians) when it is recited to them, fall down on their faces in humble prostration. And they say glory be to our Lord! Truly the promise of our Lord must be fulfilled. And they fall down on their faces weeping and it adds to their humility" (17:107-109)  

has been related on the authority of Abû Hurayrah (ra) who said: "I heard the Messenger of Allâh (saw) say:

  "Seven will be granted the shade of Allâh on a day when there will be no shade but His. A just ruler, a youth who has been brought up worshipping Allâh, a man whose heart is attached to the mosque, two people who love each other for the sake of Allâh and meet and part upon that, a man who is allurred by a woman of high standing and beauty and he says, "I fear Allâh", one who gives charity in secret so that his left hand does not know what his right hand has given, and a man whose eyes fill up with tears when he remembers Allâh in private" (Bukhârî, Muslim and others)  

  "The fire will not touch a man who weeps out of the fear of Allâh until the milk returns to the b*****s. Also the dust produced in jihâd and the smoke of h**l will never co-exist". (on the authority of Abû Hurayrah (ra), reported at-Tirmidhî (hasan sahîh), an-Nasâ'i and al Hâkim (sahîh))  

The Prophet (saw) said:

On the authority of 'Uqbah ibn 'Amir (ra) who asked

  "I said, O Messenger of Allâh! What is salvation?" He replied: "To have control over your tongue, to be content with your house and to weep over your errors". (Reported by Ibn al Mubarâk in az-Zuhd, Ahmad, at-Tirmidhî, and others, sahîh)

On the authority of Usâmah ibn Zayd (ra) who said:

  "We were with the Prophet (saw) when one of his daughters send a messenger calling for him, informing him that her small child or her son was dying. So the Prophet (saw) told the messenger: "Return to her and inform her that whatever Allâh takes and gives belongs to Him and that everything has an appointed term, so let her be patient and anticipate Allâh's reward in the hereafter". Later the messenger returned to the Prophet (saw) and said, "Verily she has sworn by Allâh that you come to her". So the Prophet (saw) got up and so too did Sa'ad ibn 'Ubâdah and Mu'âdh ibn Jabal, and I too went with them. The small boy was lifted up to the Prophet (saw) and let out a groaning noise[2], as if he was breathing his last breath. Thereby the Prophet's eyes (saw) overflowed with tears. Upon this Sa'd asked: "What is this, O Messenger of Allâh?" He (saw) replied: "This is a mercy which Allâh puts in the hearts of His servants. And verily Allâh shows mercy to those of His servants who are merciful" (al Bukhârî, Muslim)  

Answer 3

Peace...

When u are prayer, the only thing you should be crying about is the beautiful words of the Quran or because u fear Allah.

However, if u think about someone else, this shows that u are not fully concentrated on Alllah in prayer and that means that the prayer is not accepted.

If you remember Jahannam and cry then it is allowed in prayer and may allah reward you for crying for being fearfull of him and the hereafter..

Remember crying is a good because it softens the heart, many of us have hard hearts today where we reject prayer and still call ourselves muslims. Crying softens the heart and purifies it...

Inshallah all ur worries will be gone, and ask me if u need any more help..

Peace

Answer 4

Wll 2 maybe Salman, because your supposed tobe thinking of Allah SWT and your salat and duah so if your crying you should be crying to Allah.

Allah SWT will take the prayer of one that is doing it wrong all their life but with good intention, rather than one that knows how to pray and does it not well.

Answer 5

give Ur  full concentration on salah

u can cry in pray (dua)

Answer 6

Good question ;)

Answer 7

no , it;s not for no. 1 & 3..

but i donnu much about no. 2..

always love and peace ..