Question for pro illegal alien folks using the we are all immigrants line?

Question

People like to throw out the "we (or you) are all immigrants in America" line as a comeback to the illegal alien debate. Beside the obvious fact that we are living in the year 2008 and all that is history, do you think if this land still belonged to the indigenous people that anyone coming over the border illegaly would be given the welfare and other handouts they are now? Or do you even see that you are doing exactly what you accuse the current citizens of doing - coming into this country, disregarding its inhabitants, in many cases killing, maiming and raping its people? Only difference being, that back then there were no laws against illegal immigration. Do you not see the hypocrisy in your statements?

Answer 1

Actually, first we conquered the indigenous people. Then we imported people from all over the world.

But, most importantly, we only wanted white Europeans. So, we discriminated against every other race. Irish, blacks, Chinese, Latinos (Spanish), everyone at one time or another in the beginning except for white Europeans/English were discriminated against.

We whiteys (back in the the beginning of colonization) used the same arguments you are using now to justify our abhorrent behavior, from job/housing discrimination to slavery.

It is same to see that after 200 years, your mind is as small as those people.

We are not "pro illegals"

We can not stop them from crossing the border

We can not stop them from marrying our citizens

We cannot round up and ship 11 million illegals from our country. (h**l, we can't even find Osama Bin Laden)

We can not allow poor children to suffer and die because of their parents actions.

There is a problem and the solution lies with republican capitalists!

Illegals are cheap labor, giving bigger profits to companies. Most people don't complain or ask to many questions when they can buy things cheap. If you want to solve the illegal problem, stop buying from companies that employ them.

Also...

Why not offer a path to citizenship by having them serve in your republican war. They can enlist, learn English (the military teaches all languages. We need to increase our military personnel. So, if they serve our country they and their immediate family should become legal citizens of this country.

Also,

The case of illegal immigration came to the forefront after 9 - 11    the funny thing is, that it has not turned from worrying over terrorists and they getting here illegally (FROM CANADA) to worrying about Mexicans...tisk tisk...

What about the European illegals, the Canadian illegals, etc. No one ever talks about them...oh, that's right....they are white.

Answer 2

We were all immigrants.  We were not all illegal immigrants.  We are a more refined society with laws that should reflect ethics.  These illegals have none.  Since they want to reference the times of Americans being immigrants, can I start shooting these people for claim staking on my land?

Answer 3

Have the fools who have answered this question got one brain between them? That's what I would like to know. We're in a vastly different age now and what was done in times past was done by people who are long dead. Saying it serves you right, when none of us were around then, on whichever side of the divide, is like shouting abuse at a grave stone and then beating up someone's grandson in revenge.

You people are devoid of logic and sense and it makes me despair for the future of the human race and democracy.

We grew up and became civilised whereas the immigrants who are taking over our countries with your spineless, ignorant capitulation are still living in the far distant past.

The white man was thrown out of Rhodesia (Zimbabwe) and now the black man has self-rule all they have gained is torture, murder, rape, starvation and brutality and you traitors to your own people seem to welcome and applaud all these steps back into the grim past. And have you never heard of two wrongs don't make a right? Or are you too busy being holier than thou and being right-on?

I'm English and my culture and my people are being wiped out by migrants, muslims, europe and politically correct imbeciles like you.

Let me ask you a question: Do you celebrate the destruction of the World Trade Centre and all the loss of life? Do you support the thugs who did that horrific thing to innocent people? Do you support the scum that blew up 48 innocent people in London for no good reason other than that they were told they would get to s***w two dozen virgins in heaven if they did so? Well you must going by your sickening support of these dirtbags.

In London on the aniversary of our 7/7, Abu Qatada, Bin Ladens right hand man, was wandering the streets smirking his head off after being freed from prison. We can't deport him because of his human rights because something bad might happen to him if we send him home. We, the taxpayers, are shelling out a million pounds a year to keep this scumbag. He lives on welfare in free housing and preaches hate against us and our culture and tells young men to blow us up and we have to put up with it.

This is my enemy, your enemy and the enemy of free people everywhere and we are keeping him in luxury while he laughs and sneers at us and begs others to kill us at all costs.

I think I am probably a lot older than most of you, and clearly vastly more intelligent, and I am telling you now there will come a time when you will look back on your ridiculous cowardly arguments and have great cause to regret them.

Remember this. Just remember it. And when your culture has been wiped out, when your women are wearing veils, when your children are being murdered for not conforming to their beliefs and not ours, then you will look in the mirror and hate yourselves for the fools that you are today.

Call me anything you like, because I will have the last laugh as you mourn the loss of your liberty and all your much vaunted claims of freedom.

In britain we now have a law that says employers can discriminate against white people in favour of black people, that's the world you have coming and I hope you enjoy it.

Blind, gutless, cretins each and every one of you and likely deserving of what's coming to you.

Bend over and be buttfuc*ked like we are, why don't you. Hope you enjoy it.

Answer 4

When my mother's parents immigrated to the US they LEGALLY obtained citizenship, and by default my mother (who was 6 years old at the time) became a naturalized citizen. Since my grandparents were forced to go through the legal process of obtaining permission to live and work in the United States, is it really that unreasonable to expect the next generation of immigrants to respect my countries laws the way my grandparents did?

Answer 5

Bubbles, that thing of "back then there were no laws" is discriminatory, racist, and a lawer's argument

You are rigth. It is a racist fact

I thought it too about the chimp

Answer 6

They can try and call me, or my parents, or my grandparents, or my great grandparents immigrants, but I looked up immigrant in the dictionary, and my immediate family are not immigrants of any kind and nobody can ever tell me any different.  We were born in the U.S. thus making us by definition non-immigrants.

I think many of those people that use that line don't even know the meaning of immigrant, they are just throwing out any bull they can to try and defend illegal invasion.