Question for shias ?

Question

according to u , it's ok to have muta'a without "wali" , right?

if some one came and ask u to have muta'a , would u accept?

Answer 1

I will still ask your SISTER.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 2

Muta has been outlawed by our Holy Prophet (PBUH), therefore this practice should not be taking place in the first place. The people who are practicing Muta have strayed far from Islam, and the Quran tells us not to waste our time with disbeliever which the Shia's are big in disbelief !i

Answer 3

I've always wondered, what happens if say a man and woman did a 1 day or 1 week muta, and the girl ends up pregnant. And the next week he did muta with another girl and she gets pregnant. sick people out there i tell you

Answer 4

PREMARITAL s*x IS HARAAM GET IT ILLEGAL, FORBIDDEN, NOT ALLOWED EVERYWHERE IN ISLAM GET IT RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Answer 5

I've seen sinnis do muta all the time.  All you listen to is "only shia's do it because they are wrong".

Half the things each sect says that the other is doing wrong is actually regional, and both sects do it.

Answer 6

if the girl is a virigin, than she needs her parents permission, most likely they will say no

and Moez is right, i personally know 2 sunni's who do mutah, and i swear by Allah, i have never met any shia who do or have done mutah

but whatever. it doesnt matter we say does it?

Answer 7

If Mut'a is Haraam, why did Asma Bin Abu Bakr do it? For evidence, refer to Tafseer Mazhari Qadhi Thanaa Allah , page 577.