Rajhastan Royals r going to lodge complaint against shahweag , are they right?

Question

Rajhastan Royals r going to lodge complaint against shahweag , are they right?

Answer 1

Warne is complainting too much. He should be thankful to his goood luck so far.

Answer 2

Sehwag was right in demanding for third umpire's decision.

SO WAS SOURAV earlier.

And that match was Sehwag's. Shane Watson was out 3 times.

The match would have gone to DD.

Answer 3

It is wrong !

Answer 4

Technology should be used.

Neither RR are wrong,nor Sehwag.

Why don't they use the technology if it's available?

Answer 5

Obviously no. Why should Sehwag and team pay for mentally retarded umpiring?

Answer 6

Umpire's decision is final

Soon every player will ask to go to third umpire for LBW appeal. It is simple that Indians will support Sehwag

Answer 7

no they r  not right

Answer 8

yes

Answer 9

Of course they are wrong we are Indians and only we can run up to the umpires screaming like girls and not playing in the spirit of the game, that's what we told the bad Aussies in test series.

We above the gentleman's rules of the game, for we are India, we don't have to play by the rules, we have 4 players run up to umpire putting pressure on him, we are all umpires, but when punter done it, ask a question in civil way, we all said he was cheater, guys we are a laughing stock of world, we cannot have it both ways,  why can't we accept that we are bad sports and move on, we defend our crooks all the time, i am ashamed of the players and the users who defend them, no matter wat evidence there is,

one thing i did notice is glen mcgrath didn't run up telling like girly girls. oh yes , he is an Aussie, maybe they are good sports after all.

i am proud Indian mans, don't pick on me brothers, just accept we need to change our ways.

Answer 10

They are certainly wrong.They should not lodge a complaint Sehwag was well within his rights in demanding for third umpire's decision. After all, it WAS a run out and the umpires on field were judging it wrong.The should just accept the fact that a right decision was made because Sehwag was persistent .

Answer 11

No they are not right.Shane warne must exceo that his batsman was out and this complaint may become another darkspot on cricket,s new face IPL.

Answer 12

no thy shul not as it was th umpires fault he shuld hav first only taken the 3rd umpire option

Answer 13

They are totally wrong! Shane Watson was run out.....we all saw that! Why the h**l is Shane Warne always complaining? First he did it with Sourav Ganguly (he was not out though) & now he is doing the same with Sehwag! I think Sehwag was totally right by appealing for that run out......

Answer 14

According to the laws,they (RR)  are  right

But  the batsman.Watson,was clearly out  and the umpire refused to refer the decision to the third umpire.

    So,Sehwag's mistake was not a big one,he didn't accept the

umpire's  faulty decision .

Answer 15

its wrong

Answer 16

no they r not right if the player r sure that the player is out then they can request for third empire

Answer 17

RR team are playing by the book, but they are violating the, spirit of the game, played!

Answer 18

They definitely r, Y shdnt they?

Umpire's decision is the Last decision, though they asked it to be reffred by the Third Umpire, but by the time the replay was already shown on the TV Screen, and it was clearly shown that Watson was out, but what if the TV Replay had not been shown. Would they have gone for the Third Umpire then aswell? I dnt think so

Answer 19

They are wrong.Why should they lodge a complaint? Wasn't Sehwag right in demanding for third umpire's decision?After all, it WAS a run out and the umpires on field were judging it wrong.The should just shut their mouth and accept the fact that a right decision was made because Sehwag was persistent and didn't give up on the decision.

Hey Akhil,why don't you stop being a loser and start using your own brain to write down a sentence rather than copy someone else's words?

Answer 20

They are right.  Umpire's decision is final, whether it's right or wrong.  A real sportsman should not have argued with the umpire.   It has happened previously also so many times.

Answer 21

What Sehwag did was perfectly ok; and he managed the PR part of it well too - instead of blaming the on-field umpires for a bad decision, he blamed the lack of communication between the third umpire and the on-field umpires for the oversight.

Shane Warne is trying to do what he always did as an Australian cricketer - play mindgames with the opposition. Thankfully, Sehwag doesn't get affected by theatrics.

Just a side note to Maggi, Sehwag is not spelt Shewag; so, before you advise others to spell names correctly, take care to do so yourself.

Answer 22

Whatever they do atleast shane warne is not doing anything. Sehwag is right at his place and Royals are right too.

Answer 23

no they can not because a captain has a power to ask umpire

Answer 24

yes,what shewag did violates the rules  ganguly did the same , asking for third umpiries decision without the permission of the umpiries is outrageous i think both have to respect umpiries even though they are wrong. here z my sugestion ,try to write names without spelling mistakes

Answer 25

Why lodge complaint? They won the match didn't they? And it was a run-out. What's the use of Third Umpire then? And after making him out, that guy was HUMILIATED. Good Riddance to bad rubbish.

Answer 26

i dont think so

Answer 27

NO

Answer 28

No they are just crying when they do not have their way. Keeps complaining about other Captains.

Sehwag was right.

He should complain. His team lost for WRONG umpiring and the points should not go to RR.

Shane W is acting like a typical Aussie. With Greg Chappel supporting him.

Ajay Jadeja cornered Chappel yesterday on this point.

IPL should redo their rules.