Ramadan section, hey ppl, why do you ask such questions as Sunni , Shia?

Question

hey ppl, why do you ask such questions as Sunni , Shia. I think you need to stop doing such things.

Some nonmuslim people started opening such topics , and now muslims are continuing such things. Please stop this.

If a person says the Shahadah and heartly confirms it , that person is a muslim . No one of us is perfect, and we don't have the right to judge!

Answer 1

Majority (not all now, dont get me wrong).. only ask these questions to stir up controversy amongst the muslim brotherhood as a whole..

We used to not fight among each other in the past.. this is a recent issue.. I think the west has a lot to do with this.. Cause it keeps tentions upset in the middle east when we are fighting against ourselves and not focused on them..

We need to get back to one unity, one brotherhood and be charitable amongst our brothers in Islam again...  

Answer 2

I agree.

There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is His Messenger.

love for all, hatred for none

Answer 3

I agree with you, but they're not going to stop on others' behalf.

Answer 4

i totally agree with you...islam shouldn't be divided...we're gettting out of the true religion.. come on guys..we're All muslims and that's it.

Answer 5

i agree however some people are sunni and some are shia and some just have different belife and need a bit of clrarfication but at the end it doesnt even matte rall that matetrs is that you have good soul =)

Answer 6

Azeri boy = I agree with you 100% . When I came to this section I was expecting a little more love from the people here whom I assumed where great Muslims who love all. As I answered questions I realized they all had thumbs down etc The majority of people here are Sunni Muslims. I am a Shia and I think like you said,  'If a person says the Shahadah and heartly confirms it , that person is a muslim' and that is exactly what our GOD has told us. But then when 'THEY' say that Shia Muslims are Kuffar etc it really is annoying, because who are we to decide who is going to heaven or h**l or who a kaffir is etc.

After you have asked this question the ignorance continues =( Unfortunately Muslims will never be one loving group anymore.

EDIT = For the arrogant people who attack the asker. He is not saying to completely stop asking questions about others beliefs (and you know that it's not what he means) just ask them politely and show some respect to all the Muslims here. How much clearer to people have to be before you attack them. Sheeesh.

EDIT = Although I am somewhat concerned about your answer here: (people will think you are a hypocrite) http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

You are calling people who practice Muta 'kuffar' and one step closer to the edge??

Answer 7

What's wrong with asking questions and wanting to learn more about other peoples beliefs?  

Answer 8

1. saying the Shahadah and heartly confirming it  doesn't Makes one a "Muslim"(submitter).

2. If we Muslims don't have the right to Judge others ,  What is the purpose of Shariah { Qur'an , sunnah , Ijma , Giyas ] ? tell me ?