Really big baseball trade! I need advice..?

Question

I have Miguel Cabrera, and have been offered Ryan Braun.

No doubt Cabrera has been disappointing so far, but he can flat out hit. It's a long season and I think he'll end the year strong. In my league, Cabrera is 1B and 3B eligible.

As for Braun, he has been picking up his game. His numbers look great. My only issue is that I'm in a league that counts Walks and Strikeouts (Two areas that actually hurt Braun's value). In my league he is 3B and LF eligible.

Both are great hitters. Who would you rather have?

Answer 1

Ryan Braun

Answer 2

Keep Miguel Cabrera.

he will turn it around with the rest of the Tigers offense.

He's valuable piece to any team, sure he has disappointed tremendously this year, but he will give you a typical Miguel Cabrera season. Plus he walks more than Braun and strikes out less.

Braun he is also valuable with the ability to play 2 positions, like Cabrera, but I will assume that Miguel will drive in more runs this year. Plus Cabrera is a PROVEN player.

Braun only one great year sets him apart.

Jack

Answer 3

I guess it depends who you have in LF.  But personally, I'd go with Braun.

Answer 4

Id rather have Braun.