Regarding naturalizados, which would you prefer?

Question

To win with naturalizados, or lose with all Mexican-born players?

NOT AT ALL saying this is the realistic choice - just asking as a hypothetical. Because it's interesting.

To illustrate, which is better:

Beat US 2-1 with half the squad born in various South American countries.... or

Lose to US 2-1 with entire squad born in Mexico.

Answer 1

I prefer to lose to the US 2-1 because with the other option

it wasn't Mexico who beat them but 5 Mexicans and 6 other

talented South Americans. Thus the victory wouldn't be the

same and the Americans themselves would state, "you weren't capable of beating us with your own talent." And that right there is something I never want to hear because Mexico has enough talent to go one on one with any football team on this planet. That doesn't mean we will always come out victorious but we can manage to hold our own.

Edit: Aztec Soldier besides Zinha and maybe Leandro which I have doubts everyone else wants to use Mexico as a path to a World Cup. Franco once stated that he would play for South Africa as long as he went to a World Cup and that is the only reason he chose Mexico. Alfredo Moreno is soon becoming a citizen and I guarantee you many will want

him in the National team and since Argentina doesn't

want him he'll choose Mexico as gateway to the World

Cup.

Edit: As long as you have Mexican blood I don't

mind. So you be born anywhere in the world as

long as you have Mexican blood in you.

Answer 2

I doubt is going to be even half of the squad naturalize. Probably 3 or 4, but no more. I dont think is a bad idea, since most of the nations and clubs are doing that (giving players their new nationaly and letting them play) and if they want to played and represent that country why not give them a chance to see how it goes down the path..

Answer 3

why are peaple talkin bout naturalizados so much .....yall are acting like mexicos the only team to use them and your acting like the whole team is composed of them when theres only 3 or 4 ....the USA has had 3 for a wile and u dnt hear no body say anythnk and they keep gettin foregin young players

JOZY ALTIDORE---from HAITI

FREDDY ADU--AFRICAN

ONUCHI ONYEWYU---AFRICAN

EDU--ALSO FROM AFRICA

LOOK AT ITALY WITH MAURO CAMORANESI WHO IS ARGENTINIAN

LOOK AT TURKEY WITH HALF THERE TEAM BEING BRAZILIAN AND SWISS AND THERE GETTIN GOOD

so stop talkin bout mexicos 4 naturalizados they are MEXICAN CITIZENS sure there not as mexican as pepe down the street or paco sellin tacos and tamales but they are still MEXICAN CITIZENS  

Answer 4

pathhhetic!

Answer 5

lose with all mexicans!

i dont want no one born outside of mexico and usa playing for mexico

Answer 6

Naturalizados.

These people chose to reject their nationality and embrace ours. Thats huge.

Half the squad is unrealistic. Theres only like 3,4. If HALF the squad was naturalizado then I might begin to worry. But thumps up from me