Reggie Williams or Sidney Rice?

Question

Which WR would you take and why? I'll give points.

Answer 1

Wow it's like chosing between sticking your wee wee in a bear trap or cutting your leg off with a plastic butter knife. They'll both lead you nowhere, but if you must keep one, Williams has better career numbers, and a better quarterback. We will be opposite a decent reciever in Jerry Porter. Sidney Rice is playing across a better reciever in Bernard Berrian, but his quarterback sucks, and Rice is showing slow progress. Viking fans are always looking for the next Moss, and sadly it's not Sidney Rice.

Answer 2

Rice...why are people chossing Williams? "because he has a better passing game"...well you only get the receiver and not the QB

Answer 3

Reggie Williams never blossomed as a top-ten pick, and is looking more like a third or fourth rounder. Sidney Rice is too young to expect greatness out of, but he has good speed, good hands, and hasn't flopped as Williams has.

Just because of potential Rice is the better option. Plus, he has a great WR last name.

Answer 4

Rice has better skills but Williams has a better passing game.

Answer 5

reggie williams. the jaguars have a MUCH better passing game than the vikings.

Answer 6

Sidney Rice. He's gonna be a phenom.