Been offered this trade?

Question

i get: carlos lee

they get: ben sheets

or

i get: grady sizemore

they get: roy halladay

which one should i accept?

my lineup, 10 team H2H:

C: posada

1B: morneau

2B: roberts

3B: m. cabrera

SS: michael young

OF: josh hamilton

OF: alex rios

OF: vlad

Util: jay bruce

Util: kevin youkilis

Util: vernon wells

BN: todd helton

BN: jeff francoeur

BN: joey votto

BN: robinson cano

DL: tulo

SP: halladay

SP: hamels

SP: cc sabathia

SP: ben sheets

SP: verlander

RP: krod

RP: fuentes

BN: rich harden

pitchers on waiver are: dustin mcgowan, matt cain, armando galarraga

Answer 1

i see keep your team the way it is.....your offense is great, and votto is great and you should somehow get him in your lineup....i think that your offense is fine, and adding more will just mean you will have to sit another great player.....pitching is great to have a surplus in because you can rotate them daily.....i think Lee > Sheets and Seizmore > Roy, but with the team you have, you are probably doing very good, and i think you should just stay with what you have.....if anything, package halladay or sheets with one of your great OF, to get an even better OF....or  package sheets with someoen in your hitting, to get a better SP

Answer 2

I like both of those trades.Build up your starting offence as much as you can,then package some nonstarters for SPs.

Then in your empty spots pick up more SPs/closers...

This is a tried and true strategy that works repeatedly. Excellent starters on offence,and a large quantity of SPs and closers.Sizemore+C.Lee could power your team through the playoffs...Some package trade offer ideas could be something like; Vlad+Cano for J.Santana,,,,,and Wells+ Helton for R.Oswalt.

Answer 3

get sizemore he way beter then lee and sheets will give u some good outings

Answer 4

Take the Sizemore deal. He's a top 25 player and losing Halladay won't affect your pitching in any way.

Answer 5

That tough Halladay as been a complete game machine. I would do the 1st trade. Ben Sheets is always hurt and can not be counted on. Carlos Lee will be a great source of power and RBI's and should help out your outfield. Your pitching would still be good without Sheets, if you lose Holliday that would hurt your pitching more.