Blockbuster fantasy baseball deal! Need help!?

Question

Team A gets:

1B P. Fielder

2B R. Cano

3B K. Youkillis

SS E. Renteria

OF A. Dunn

SP S. Marcum

Team B gets:

1B A. Gonzalez

2B C. Utley

3B A. Ramirez

SS R. Furcal

OF H. Matsui

RP G. Sherrill

Who wins this one? Why?

Answer 1

B with out a doubt o and yooukkk  sucks second half

Answer 2

Team B. Enough said.

Answer 3

Man, you should've known who wins the instant you look at this deal. If you are the owner of Team B, you'll instantly know that you've ripped Team A off badly.

Prince Fielder is good at homers, but that's about it. Plus, he lacks speed. Meanwhile, Adrian Gonzalez is leading the NL in RBI, and also owns a good amount of home runs. I think Gonz will probably have around 103-112 RBI by season's end, and about 29-33 homers.

Utley is better than Cano one hundred times. Period.

Aramis Ramirez beats out Youkilis by a lot. Youkilis has good amount of RBI early in the season because batters in front of him reach base quite often. Now, Youk is looking like the Youk before, in a deep slump. Aramis, meanwhile, still wallops homers and drives in batters easily.

Furcal will beat out Renteria by a lot, too, when he returns to the Dodgers. However, that's just my prediction, because Furcal may slump a bit after being injured. Who knows, but Furcal wins this one.

Matsui and Dunn are quite even. In the BA category, Matsui defeats Dunn easily, as Matsui is consistent all season. Dunn beats out Matsui in RBI and HR, but Matsui beats out Dunn in hits. Just a bit even here.

Okay, finally, Team A wins this one. Shaun Marcum is officially the second ace of the Blue Jays, beside Halladay. Sherill is good at saves, but Marcum is definitely better, having a decent ERA and K's while winning games.

Team B wins this trade.

Answer 4

Obviously team B.

Fielder vs. Gonzalez.  Gonzalez is crazy hot right now.  You can't compete.

Cano vs. Utley.  Utley is amazingly hot.  Cano is slumping.

Youkillis vs. Ramirez.  Ramirez is much better than Youkillis.  Youkillis had a hot streak, but that's over now.

Renteria vs. Furcal.  Furcal is overall better, but he's on the DL.  Team A wins that one.

Dunn vs. Matsui.  This one's basically a tie.  Matsui's the hottest Yankee right now, Dunn is pretty good too.

Marcum vs. Sherill.  Marcum probably wins one, but it depends on who needs what in terms of pitchers.

Answer 5

Team B would be the right choice, besides who in the MLB is have a better season C. Utley or even A. Ramirez of the cubs.

Answer 6

team B chase utley's there so they automaticly win

Answer 7

i say team B wins utley and gonzo r on this yr and if furcal comes back strong then it will be a steal

Answer 8

Hmm Im getting the other one got rejected?

This seems closer but I still like team B.

i really dont want to go over teh same thing in your other Q so just check out my opinions on that Q on the same players.

On the separate ones though, ill tell you how i feel.

Youk, Dunn, Marcum for Matsui, Aram, Sherrill. I still like the B side becayse Aram is way better than Dunn and Matsui is way better than Youk and Sherrill is doing so good so you cant trade him for a mid tier SP like marcum.

Team B is STILL anialating Team A in this trade.