Brad Lidge for Nate McLouth?

Question

Fair trade?

Answer 1

i wouldnt do it..... cause lidge doesnt get many save oppurtunities

Answer 2

yes

Answer 3

Are you talking about the Phillies and Pirates making a trade, or is this a fantasy question?

Answer 4

Are you talking about a fantasy trade or a real one?

If it's a fantasy trade, it's a pretty good trade.  McLouth has good HR and R numbers, and Lidge is doing well at saves.

As a real trade, it wouldn't be great simply because the Pirates need outfielders more than they need relievers right now.

Answer 5

No, Nate Mclouth is 27 to Lidge being 32 and you give up an everyday player for a reliever.

Answer 6

It highly depends on your needs.  If you need a closer or if you need an OF.  Straight up, its a fair trade.

Lidge is perfect in save chances this year with a microscopic ERA.  McLouth with a breakout year.  A possible 30hr/20steal year with 100rbi/100run.

Answer 7

it depends if u trade lidge u need to have another closer cause he is 28 out 28 in saves this year

ps i have both