Do you agree with Ian Chappell?

Question

Ian Chappell says that Brad Haddin will be a better wicket keeper than Gilly.

Do you agree?

coz, I don't.

Answer 1

I'd never agree with Ian chappell .

Answer 2

I respect Ian's cricket knowledge and depth.  Lets wait and see.

Answer 3

No.I will never agree.

Gilly is the all time best.

Answer 4

I think he's been inhaling too much funny weed! lol. I would hope that was true, but it's not. Brad is good, but his batting leaves a lot to be desired.Don't get me wrong, he's a handy batsman, but not in Gilly's class. As a keeper, who knows how he'll go.

Answer 5

It is too early to jump to conclusions.  Time alone will prove who is better.

Answer 6

He would not have said something like  this without thinking anything .we all know how good gilly is ,but how can we comment on haddin ,

                                      But in my book ,gilly is the best keeper australia had,if something better than him comes in world cricket ,that will be equally praised ..

Piyush(For latest cricketDiscussions )

http://piyushthakur.blogspot.com/

Answer 7

no' i dont agree with Ian chappell

Answer 8

No

Answer 9

no... no one would come close to gilly, not that i like him tho

Answer 10

dont agree

Answer 11

Chappell has always been given to making rash statements, and this is no different. Haddin may well become as good as Gilchrist in keeping, but there's no way his batting will even touch gilchrist's.

Answer 12

nopoe,who cares about what Ian Chappell has to say?

Answer 13

Even if Haddin take 500 dismisals I would still not agree with Ian Chappel cause hes a goose.

Answer 14

too early to say. ask me after 10 years.

Answer 15

no i am not agree with ian

Answer 16

I don't agree with Chappell. Gilchrist is one of the greatest wicket-keepers in world cricket!!!

Answer 17

I will let you know when Haddin is as old as Gilly is now.

Answer 18

Chappell probably is breaking up the team as he has done before.

Gilly is far above even Chappells thoughts. He is not thinking or is on purpose, misleading.

Take his name and my blood boils.

Answer 19

Of course I don't agree................Adam Gilchrist is one of the best wicketkeeper- batsman in the world.....There is no doubt that he is the perfect one for the job...There is no question of replacing him................Tell Chappell to get a life

Answer 20

well that's an opinion it's not a fact...

i don't agree yet...I don't even understand how chappell can come out with a statement like this. Brad Haddin shouldn't have to come into cricket thinking he has to be as good if not better than one of the greats...Adam Gilchrist.

giving him a big expectation like this is wrong..in my OPINION.

Answer 21

tell him to shut the **** up!!!



GILLY is of course better.

Answer 22

No, but we all know Chappell is a biased idiot. He doesn't even try to hide it.