Donovan McNabb or David Garrard?

Question

Who Would You Rather Have On Your Fantasy Team???? And Why?

Answer 1

Garrard

he less injured and less likely to thrown an INT

Answer 2

Garrard, without question, since McNabb is normally injured and out for the year very early in the season.

Answer 3

dovan manabb he is stating quaterback and like the 6 th best quarter back

Answer 4

McNabb if he stays healthy and plays the entire season. He has a lot if injury problems, though he is like one of the top five QBs right now. Garrard in is first full season as a starter. McNabb has a little speed left in him, but all the surgeries may have affected that attribute.

Answer 5

David Garrard. He is more consistent and he wont get injured that easily like McNabb. So to me the choice is easy.

Answer 6

Without a doubt McNabb. He is one of the best in the league when healthy and at his best at least in the top 5. I went to Eagles training camp and McNabb looked as good as he ever was. Definitely McNabb.

Answer 7

McNabb. Both are injury risks, but McNabb has much better targets, including Brian Westbrook, who can make things happen on screen passes. Also, his mobility in the preseason has been great, so I would not be surprised if he is a top 3 QB if he can stay healthy all year. Garrard does not have the same upside, but is still an injury risk. However, that risk is lower than McNabbs, so if you want a safer pick, go with Garrard, but I think McNabb has a much better chance to lead your team to victory.

Answer 8

garrard, mcnabb is always getting injured. i would pick mcnabb over garrard if injuries weren't a factor. but garrard.  

Answer 9

i was about to ask this question